Industry effort to force EPA rules on FQPA dead this year

29 June 2000 22:53  [Source: ICIS news]

WASHINGTON (CNI)--Industry-supported legislation to force the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to change the way it implements a 1996 federal food safety law appeared dead for the year Thursday after a key House committee chairman said his panel would not consider the bill.

House Commerce Committee Chairman Tom Bliley (Republican-Virginia) said Thursday in a speech that "The administration is opposed. The environmental community is opposed. It is not going to become law this year."

The bill, introduced in April 1999 by Representative Richard Pombo (Republican-California), would require the EPA to issue formal rules, rather than guidance policies, as it carries out the requirements of the Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA).

The 1996 FQPA law requires the agency to re-evaluate the safety of nearly 10 000 registered uses of pesticide over a 10-year period under a new, more stringent risk assessment standard.

Under the Pombo bill, EPA would have to use sound science and the best available "real-world" data when making decisions on pesticides uses. If reliable data are not available, registrants and others would have to provide it according to EPA guidelines.

But with the US general elections approaching, Bliley said, "I'm not going to bring it up and have my guys cast as anti-environmentalists."

The legislation is strongly opposed by environmental and consumer activists, who contend the measure would prevent the EPA acting quickly to protect children from unsafe pesticide exposures.

The pesticide industry and agricultural groups counter that the legislation is needed to prevent the unnecessary loss of essential crop protection chemicals and to ensure a transparent, predictable regulatory process.

Bliley said he is "concerned" that EPA is making hasty decisions about many pesticide uses, referring to recent agency actions against three widely-used organophosphate insecticides.

The FQPA does not suggest that EPA should make decisions about pesticides based on draft documents, policies or guidelines, he noted. "Nothing in the law compels EPA to adopt unreasonable safety standards or overly conservative risk assessments," Bliley added.

He also expressed concern that EPA is ignoring reliable data in making decisions about pesticides, and is instead relying on theoretical "worst-case" assumptions. The FQPA requires EPA to use valid, complete and reliable science, said Bliley.

The Pombo bill has been endorsed by 233 of the House of Representative's 435 members, while an identical measure pending in the 100-member Senate has 40 co-sponsors.

By: Glenn Hess
+1 713 525 2653

For the latest chemical news, data and analysis that directly impacts your business sign up for a free trial to ICIS news - the breaking online news service for the global chemical industry.

Get the facts and analysis behind the headlines from our market leading weekly magazine: sign up to a free trial to ICIS Chemical Business.

Printer Friendly