06 May 2010 17:06 [Source: ICIS news]
By Joe Kamalick
Various environmental and other interest groups have renewed calls for re-imposition of the broad offshore oil and gas drilling ban that barred energy development in some 85% of US outer continental shelf (OCS) regions for nearly 30 years.
That OCS drilling ban - which affected US offshore regions along the nation’s Atlantic and Pacific coasts and for much of Alaska’s coastline - was allowed to expire in late 2008 when record-high domestic gasoline prices made the congressional and presidential drilling moratoria politically untenable.
However, Greenpeace executive director Philip Radford said the Gulf oil rig accident demonstrated that “The only way to prevent human, economic and environmental tragedies like the BP Deepwater Horizon disaster is to re-enact the moratorium on offshore drilling and to replace dirty, dangerous fuels with clean energy”.
The Center for Biological Diversity (CBD) said that the Gulf catastrophe dispels claims that offshore drilling is safe.
CBD has moved to file suit against the US Department of the Interior (DOI) to force reversal of the department’s recent approval for Shell Oil to begin exploratory drilling in the Beaufort and
“Such a position is now clearly untenable,” said Rebecca Noblin,
The Sierra Club's executive director Michael Brune said the Gulf rig explosion and resulting oil spill “is a turning point for
“Sadly, we are now witnessing one of the worst environmental disasters in American history,” Brune said, “and we will be dealing with the impacts of BP’s drilling rig collapse for decades to come.”
“We need assurance that this won’t happen again,” he added. “We need to restore the federal moratorium on drilling off
Several coastal state senators, among them Bill Nelson of Florida and Frank Lautenberg and Robert Menendez, both of New Jersey and all Democrats, have called for a new offshore drilling ban. They also demanded that President Barack Obama suspend his already modest offshore development plan, and the White House quickly complied.
California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger (Republican) also was quick to withdraw his two-year-old support for renewed oil and gas drilling off his state’s coastline, citing the Deepwater Horizon tragedy and the threat to Gulf coastal communities.
“That will not happen here in
The American Petroleum Institute (API) cautioned that the Deepwater Horizon disaster should not trigger a new offshore drilling moratorium.
“In the wake of this accident, many people are understandably concerned about the safety and environmental risks associated with offshore drilling,” said API spokeswoman Cathy Landry.
“But we should be careful not to rush to judgement on this issue until we’ve learned what went wrong,” she added.
“It would be unfortunate if this accident were used as an excuse to roll back the gains we have made in finding new ways to explore and develop our own energy resources,” she said.
Landry said that the
“This incident does not change the reality of our energy future,” she said. “The demand for energy is growing. American needs domestic sources, and oil and gas will be part of
“We must safely and responsibly pursue domestic energy production,” she added.
But the political tide may well have turned against renewed offshore development.
The nearly three-decades-long ban on drilling off the US East and West Coasts and in most of Alaska’s territorial waters was in part triggered by the 1969 blowout on Union Oil’s Platform A off the coast of Santa Barbara, California, that fouled 30 miles of coastline.
The moratoria were sustained by the 1989 Exxon Valdez tanker accident that spilled millions of gallons of crude into
Kert Davies, research director for Greenpeace in the
“This now resets the discussion,” Davies said. “We’ve been lucky, and the offshore industry has been expounding on how safe it is and selling this to
“This is clearly another marker, another Silent Spring,” Davies said, referring to the 1962 book by Rachel Carson that is widely credited with launching the environmental movement.
A Washington energy analyst said the Gulf rig disaster should not bring an end to renewed offshore exploration and development in the areas previously under moratoria.
“When there’s a major plane crash, we don’t react by shutting down commercial aviation,” he said. “We find out what went wrong and make things better, but we don’t abandon commercial aviation because of an accident, however tragic.”
But on Capitol Hill, and especially in an election year, reason and logic hold little ground against the tidal wave of political perception. Expanded
Ironically, the Deepwater Horizon tragedy also has put a final torpedo to the already foundering Senate climate change bill.
The compromise energy and climate change legislation that Senators John Kerry (Democrat-Massachusetts), Joe Lieberman (Independent-Connecticut) and Lindsey Graham (Republican-South Carolina) have hammered out - but not yet introduced - is described as a three-legged stool.
In the compromise, Senate Democrats were to accept incentives for renewed
The nuclear and offshore energy legs of the compromise were to bring enough Senate Republicans on board to support the climate bill and give it the needed 60-vote majority in the Senate.
But now, Florida’s Senator Bill Nelson and Ben Cardin of Maryland, both Democrats, are saying they won’t vote for any climate bill that includes offshore oil and gas authorisations, much less incentives.
If expanded OCS exploration and development is cut from the climate and energy bill, it will not win sufficient Republican votes, and the two-legged stool will fall over.
But Lawrence Sloan, president and chief executive of the Society of Chemical Manufacturers and Affiliates (SOCMA), said the Deepwater Horizon accident kills climate change for the rest of this year.
“This issue will further complicate any consensus to bring Republicans to the table on cap-and-trade, at least for the remainder of this year, especially with mid-term elections looming,” Sloan said.
“I just don’t see anyone stepping up to the plate and insisting on new offshore drilling as part of a comprehensive new energy bill,” he added.
And, once the November elections are over, the US House and Senate are likely to have fewer Democrats and more Republican members - and more opponents to any sort of draconian federal emissions caps.
“This is the proverbial nail in the coffin of climate change legislation,” said Greenpeace’s Davies. “A lot of people were declaring it dead anyway, even before Deepwater Horizon.”
For the latest chemical news, data and analysis that directly impacts your business sign up for a free trial to ICIS news - the breaking online news service for the global chemical industry.
Get the facts and analysis behind the headlines from our market leading weekly magazine: sign up to a free trial to ICIS Chemical Business.
|ICIS news FREE TRIAL|
|Get access to breaking chemical news as it happens.|
|ICIS Global Petrochemical Index (IPEX)|
|ICIS Global Petrochemical Index (IPEX). Download the free tabular data and a chart of the historical index|