12 June 2013 16:00 [Source: ICIS news]
By Mark Yost
"It's something that's been talked about for the past decade," said one source. "It is coming? Certainly. But not anytime soon."
Market sources that supply petchem-based plastics and resins also said that even when carbon fibre does become affordable for mass-market vehicles, it will not really compete with the parts of the car for which they provide material.
"Most of our material goes into interiors, body panels and glass," one source said. "Carbon fibre, because of its strength and light weight, is being looked at to replace frame rails and other steel parts."
The only petchem producers who are at all excited about carbon fibre are acrylonitrile (ACN) makers. That is because, depending on who you talk to, it takes 3-5 lbs of ACN to make 1 lb of carbon fibre.
Auto makers are looking at carbon fibre because it is roughly 10 times as strong as steel and a quarter of the weight. It is a material that could help them meet increasingly stringent fleet fuel-economy standards that are slated to rise to 50 mpg by 2025.
Auto makers are looking at an aerospace-grade of carbon fibre called polyacrylonitrile (PAN). But PAN costs roughly $15/lb, or about $33,000/tonne (€24,750/tonne), compared with about 40 cents/lb, or $882/tonne, for steel.
Carbon fibre is also significantly more expensive than some of the petrochemicals that go into making auto parts. The current spot price for ACN is about $1,650/tonne, while ABS is priced at about $3,000/tonne and PC costs about $3,700/tonne, depending on the grade.
Carbon fibre has other obstacles it must overcome before it can be adapted to mass-market auto making. For instance, most carbon-fibre components are made in big ovens called autoclaves that bake parts at intensely high temperatures and pressures. But the autoclave cycle-time needed to make something such as a car hood is 90 minutes. That may be good enough to make body panels, cross braces and other parts for a car like the low-volume Dodge SRT Viper, but it is not nearly fast enough for high-volume auto factories that are rolling a car off the line every 60 seconds.
At a new plant in
"We're like the Marines," Staargaard said. "We're the first to do it."
Staargaard acknowledges that the technique is still not suited to make complex shapes required for structural components such as floor pans, cross beams, door beams and pillars. Plasan is working on a less-expensive resin transfer moulding process in which carbon-fibre fabric is placed in a heated mould and resin is injected into the mould under high pressure. The process reduces production time for a component to three to 10 minutes, he said.
Despite the high cost of carbon fibre, some auto makers are integrating the high-strength, low-weight material into some products. BMW is developing a carbon fibre passenger cell for its i3 electric vehicle that debuts next year. BMW is expected to produce 30,000 units a year. The Alfa Romeo 4C sports car, which debuts this year, will have a carbon fibre chassis, according to the auto maker. Parent company Fiat SpA, which also owns Chrysler, plans to produce 2,500 of the Alfa units in the first year.
The more important point, sources said, is that neither the Alfa Romeo 4C nor the BMW i3 carry the stratospheric sticker price of a supercar such as the Lamborghini Sesto Elemento, which comes with a carbon fibre body and a $2.2m price tag.
Similarly, Ford formed a joint venture with Dow Chemical last year to develop low-cost carbon fibre suitable for high-volume production by late this decade. And Chrysler says it is exploring new uses for carbon fibre after using it for the hood, roof and deck lid on the Viper. Chrysler said just the hood alone saved 40 pounds.
With so much carbon-fibre innovation under way, market sources said it is unclear which carbon-fibre technologies will prevail. That is why auto makers are signing nonexclusive contracts with their suppliers.
"No one is going to own this market," Staargaard said. "No one is sure who has the right answer. Everybody is hedging their bets. They are keeping their options open."
Among the companies that provide petrochemical-based plastics and resins to the auto industry are Ascend Performance Materials, BASF, Dow Chemical, INEOS, Honeywell, SABIC and Styron.
($1 = €0.75)
|ICIS news FREE TRIAL|
|Get access to breaking chemical news as it happens.|
|ICIS Global Petrochemical Index (IPEX)|
|ICIS Global Petrochemical Index (IPEX). Download the free tabular data and a chart of the historical index|
Asian Chemical Connections