Map Ta Phut impasse continues

By Malini Hariharan

There is no light yet for companies whose projects have been suspended at Map Ta Phut. Last Friday, Thailand’s Central Administrative Court rejected 30 petitions submitted by companies looking to resume work as their projects had received environmental clearance and would not create pollution.

“The outlook is not promising,” says a Bangkok-based analyst. He is also not surprised by last week’s court ruling. “Nothing has changed for the court to change its mind. All the petitions had information already seen by the court. The court wants companies to follow the constitution,” he adds.

And article 67 of the Thai constitution requires health impact assessment studies to be conducted and approved by an independent committee.

The government is still struggling to put together the regulation to implement article 67 and also an independent committee.

Earlier this month, a four-party panel, headed by the country’s former prime minister Anand Panyarachun, prepared and submitted a new regulation which was approved by the cabinet. And a 19-member coordinating committee was also appointed to advise the government on approval of projects at Map Ta Phut.

But an environmental group, Stop Global Warming Association, is now seeking to block implementation of the regulation and has filed a petition with the administrative court. The NGO says that no public hearings were held while drafting the regulation despite the fact that it would affect a large number of people and organisations.

Pic Source: Pattaya Daily News

Affected companies are still trying out all options to resume work at Map Ta Phut. Siam Cement said in a statement today that it has already started to comply with the new regulations invoked by the state in accordance with article 67. The compliance process is expected to take between 8-12 months, it said.

And Siam Cement is also trying to “expedite a conclusion through consultation and coordination with official agencies concerned as well as investors to find solutions.”

Eighteen projects run by both Siam Cement subsidiaries and its joint-venture companies are among the 64 projects affected by the Supreme Court’s order to halt construction. The investment cost of these 18 projects is worth over Baht57.5bn ($1.74bn).

Siam Cement did not identify the 18 projects but according to one industry source the company’s joint-venture cracker, hdPE and PP projects are not on the list but a lldPE project is stuck. The blog has not yet been able to confirm this with the company.

Meanwhile, PTT Chem has started its new 1m tonnes/year cracker and expects to achieve on-spec production by the end of this month, reports ICIS news. But sustaining full operations at the new cracker would depend on when parent company, PTT, is allowed to commission its No6 gas separation project at Map Ta Phut.

A PTT source says that the project was 99.8% complete at the end of last year and that construction work is almost over. But after last week’s court ruling the company is not able to provide any clarity on when work can resume at the project.

PTT, says the source, plans to work with government agencies and ask them to file a fresh petition in the Administrative court. It is also evaluating approaching the Supreme Court directly. And it also working on a health impact assessment study which should be ready for evaluation by April.

“In the worst case we are looking at a one year delay in the commissioning of the gas plant,” says the source.

To keep the new cracker running, maintenance shutdowns will be carried out at PTT Chem’s two existing crackers. A 460,000 tonnes/year cracker is due to be shut in mid-February for 35 days while a 515,000 tonnes/year cracker will be shut for 30 days in June.

Extra ethane (around 600,000 tonnes/year) would also be available once PTT completes revamping two of its existing gas separation plants. The revamp project is not the list of affected projects and test runs are due in February.

But even these arrangements may not provide sufficient ethane to the new cracker. “We believe we cannot run it at 100%. We have to wait and see when we finish commissioning of the gas separation plant,” says the source.

The delay in the new gas separation plant has implications that go beyond petrochemicals as Thailand will have to import huge volumes of LPG.

“It will be around 100,000 tonnes/month and the government will have to subsidise this. They [the government] are under a lot of pressure. International prices of LPG are in the $700-800 range while the local price is around $330. The government subsidy would be around $1.5bn every month,” says the source.

But this is something that the government has known since September last year when the administrative court made its first ruling on Map Ta Phut, points out the analyst.

The Map Ta Phut mess is just one of the many problems that the beleaguered government is facing. The stock market has fallen to a seven-week low on concerns about political uncertainty.

Investors appear to be increasingly worried about an impending collapse of the current coalition government. The Bangkok Post also reports about discontent in the armed forces and rumours of a coup which have spooked the business community.

, , , , , ,

Leave a Reply