Resolving China’s Bad Debts

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Europe, US

By John Richardson

IS China facing a bad debt crisis as serious, or perhaps even worse, than sub-prime in the US and sovereign debt in Europe?

Despite all the bland reassurances the blog keeps hearing from chemical industry executives about the tremendous growth prospects in China, this is a valid question as we try to assess the prospects for 2012 and beyond.

We are not saying, as we discussed last month, that the opportunities are not indeed tremendous in China and other emerging markets.

It is just that we continue to feel that the level of debate, in public at least, doesn’t take into account the big risks China faces as it confronts its bad-debt crisis.

As we discussed yesterday, economic policy is likely to be conservative in 2012 as a leadership transition takes.

But the longer the politicians dither, the bigger the debt problem could become – as has been the case in Europe.

Ratings agency Fitch is concerned that 30% of China’s loans could turn bad, we wrote in November.

“It means that $2.5 trillion of loans might not be paid, and yet 2010 GDP was only $5.9 trillion,” we were told by our fellow blogger, Paul Hodges.

“Even if we halve Fitch’s estimate, this would still mean loans worth 21% of GDP would not be repaid. This is a big haircut even by eurozone standards.”

More recent analysis by Bloomberg tallied the debt disclosed by 231 local government financing companies that had sold bonds, notes or commercial last year – up until 10 December. The total outstanding was $622bn, more than the size of the current European bailout fund.

The article suggests that, despite official central government data to the contrary, China is failing to curb borrowing as local governments panic and borrow more money.

They are caught in a vicious circle of needing to borrow more to generate cash flow in order to meet obligations on existing borrowings.

This cash flow is being generated from completion of property projects, but real estate prices are falling in response to the central government’s deliberate policy of driving-down property prices.

A handful of property developers in Beijing reduced prices by 20 percent in mid-December, according to this report from Reuters. And even the government-controlled Xinhua news agency is reporting that overall property prices in Beijing will fall by 10-20 per cent over the next six to 12 months.

The central government will have to eventually step in to take bad debts off the books of the state-owned banks that have leant money to the local authorities.

But, as we said, the longer that Beijing waits as the new generation of leaders settles in, the bigger the problem.

What also needs to happen is for the central government to address the heart of the issue: The dependence of local authorities on land sales to raise revenue.

Exactly how do you go about dismantling, and then rebuilding, an economic system?

Firstly, you would face the need to fill the revenue shortfall confronting local authorities no longer able to depend on land sales. Land sales typically account for 40 percent of the money raised by provincial and city authorities. 

And secondly, local government officials are likely to resist change as land deals have been a tremendous source of additional income through corrupt payments.

The new generation of leaders need to find a solution not only because of the danger that the bad-debt crisis could get much worse.

One of the causes of rising social unrest is the seizure of agricultural land for commercial development, as illustrated by what happened in Wukan.

PREVIOUS POST

Wile E Coyote And China

03/01/2012

By John Richardson THE blog, a bit like Wile E Coyote who always fails to catch ...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Saudi Gas Costs Head Higher

04/01/2012

By John Richardson SAUDI Arabia’s petrochemical producers could soon, or m...

Learn more
More posts
Vaccine nationalism and lack of debt relief remain major threats to petchem growth
27/01/2021

By John Richardson WE LIVE in a highly interconnected world as this statistic underlines: of the $18...

Read
China’s economic dominance carries many short and long-term risks for petrochemicals
19/01/2021

By John Richardson JUST 5% of US companies with revenues of more than $500m plan to relocate operati...

Read
Petrochemical companies must invest more in new methods of assessing demand
17/01/2021

By John Richardson INVESTORS must look beyond measures of GDP growth if they are going to understand...

Read
New China pandemic outbreak China single-biggest risk for global petchems in 2021
14/01/2021

By John Richardson CHINA FACES another test of its pandemic control capabilities because of new outb...

Read
The energy transition and how it will define tomorrow’s petrochemical Winners
12/01/2021

    By John Richardson MOST OF the time historical events move at a snail’s pace. The me...

Read
China polyethylene imports set to remain strong in 2021 despite big local capacity growth
09/01/2021

By John Richardson IT WAS a tremendous year. China’s 2020 polyethylene (PE) demand growth over 201...

Read
Collapsing battery costs point to ever-declining forecasts for oil demand
05/01/2021

By John Richardson THE END of the oil age is arriving. Sooner than many people think, demand for oil...

Read
Sustainability means reducing carbon emissions as well as plastic waste
22/12/2020

By John Richardson THIS IS VERY much a personal plea to our industry about what I see as the biggest...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more