China: Starting All Over Again

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Europe, US

ChinaglobalStimulus

By John Richardson

WE NOW know is that China’s real GDP growth is probably heading into negative territory, perhaps by as early as Q4 – and if not by then, certainly in 2015.

But in order to fully answer “how bad will it get before it gets good again?” we need to also evaluate just how long weaker growth will last and what the implications will be for the global economy.

Here are just a few thoughts on this huge subject:

  • Nobody, really, has a clue because what China is attempting to do involves dismantling and rebuilding an entire economic growth model. To pretend otherwise is intellectually dishonest.
  • What we do know is that we have to prepare for the worst – and then “stress test” our businesses under these worst-case scenarios.
  •  Interestingly, a comment we often hear is that it is outsiders who have the bleakest view of China’s prospects. But on our recent trip to Shanghai, an “insider”, i.e. a Chinese national, told us:
  1. It will take Xi Jinping and Li Keqiang at least five years to reap any significantly positive results from the reform process.
  2.   And there are no guarantees that they will succeed at all.
  3. The reasons he gave for potential failure included the need to create a fair and transparent legal system in order to create a level playing field for innovation. Without such as level playing field, China would fail to sufficiently move up the manufacturing value chain – and so would not escape the “middle income trap”. He pointed that the entire legal system would have to be dismantled and rebuilt in order to make it fair and transparent.
  4. He also talked about the need for a renewed “values system” where people felt the need, because of a stronger sense of social responsibility, to do “the right things”. He worried that the values system had been eroded over the last few decades because growth had been pursued for the sake of growth. “Stronger legal sanctions by themselves will not be enough to stop people from cutting corners on food safety and environmental protection,” he said. Where on earth do you start here?
  5. Xi Jinping’s anti-corruption campaign is proving hugely popular – and makes a lot of sense. But at some point, the campaign will run up against the dilemma that people at levels of society, a few years before they retire, are forced to resort to graft because of the lack of a decent nationwide pensions system. How do you build such a system during a period when local government revenues are falling because the property bubble has burst?
  • And as far as the impact on the global economy goes, the above slide reminds us that since 2009, China’s economic stimulus has dwarfed that of any other central bank.
  • As the stimulus is withdrawn, this will have seven major implications for the world’s economy.

In our post yesterday, we raised two other questions, which were:

  • To what extent can the current government allow it to get bad even if they know it is for the longer term good?
  • And will the government blink too soon when it gets bad and pull back on some of the reforms?

We will attempt some answers in a post later this week.

PREVIOUS POST

China Heads For Negative Real GDP By As Early As Q4

29/09/2014

By John Richardson “BY NOW I think most folks are aware of and agree with ...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China's Polyolefins Supply Surge: The Bigger Picture

01/10/2014

By John Richardson ON paper, the polyolefins supply surge in China during 2014 i...

Learn more
More posts
Focus of petchems business must be on meeting medical and food needs
05/04/2020

By John Richardson SEVERAL contacts have said to me over the last two weeks that increased medical a...

Read
Be very, very cautious about buying into the idea of a Q2 crude price rally
03/04/2020

By John Richardson IT IS the unprecedented nature of the demand shock that’s the thing, regardless...

Read
No business as usual despite re-ordering of global polyethylene competitiveness
01/04/2020

By John Richardson THERE ARE sadly no business as usual scenarios, in my view. Under normal circumst...

Read
China: temper your expectations of a H2 recovery for supply as well as demand reasons
29/03/2020

By John Richardson CHINA IS gradually getting back to work, but only gradually because the governmen...

Read
Petrochemical feedstock purchasing managers: What to think about and what do next
27/03/2020

By John Richardson ALL THE old assumptions about how oil, feedstock and petrochemicals markets work ...

Read
Vital work to maintain petrochemicals supply for essential services must continue
26/03/2020

By John Richardson INDUSTRY associations around the world are lobbying governments about the importa...

Read
Polyethylene: How to plan sensibly as we face threat of new Global Depression
25/03/2020

By John Richardson I SINCERELY want to help you guys. That’s what I am here for. To this end, here...

Read
Coronavirus may take as much as two years to be brought under control
22/03/2020

By John Richardson The only honest answer is that none of us know how events will turn out because o...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more