China Jobs Squeeze: Why It Is Happening And What It Means

Business, China, Company Strategy, Sustainability, Technology

Jobs, jobs and jobs are the three main priorities for politicians everywhere. In the first of my series of country and region-specific posts on this subject, I look at what this means for China.



By John Richardson

SOME of those who thought that China’s investment-led growth was a sound long-term way forward are now saying: Ok, we got that wrong, but we were still right about China’s strong potential, it was just for the wrong reasons. Look at how the services sector has replaced manufacturing as a bigger driver of GDP, for example – and just look at the growth in consumer spending.

Let’s take an alternative, and I think more realistic, look at the services sector. According to Pauline Loong, managing director of Asia-analytica Research:

  • China’s net trade in services has been in negative territory since 1994. And the deficit in all but one of the past 15 years has been big enough to wipe away the benefits from the annual increase in net merchandise trade. The only exception was 2009 when manufacturing exports collapsed.
  • In 2013, a turning point was supposedly reached when the services share of GDP was bigger than manufacturing for the first time ever. But this was only in nominal terms. Strip out prices effects and manufacturing remained bigger. Preliminary data from last year suggests that this trend is continuing.
  • She writes: From pharmacists to actuaries to auto mechanics to corporate translators, the shortage of qualified professionals is do dire that the government has launched various recruitment programmes to retain local talent and attract skilled workers from overseas.

Gordon Orr, a director for McKinsey in its Shanghai office, is also, in my view, on the money when he warns that:

  • 2015 will be the year that sees the lowest annual income growth in China for at least a decade. The reason is that workers have priced themselves out of lower-value manufacturing, resulting in the migration of some of that manufacturing overseas. Chinese private companies where wage rises have been higher than the state-owned enterprises, will as a result be under enormous pressure to reduce costs.
  • One way of doing this is through automation in manufacturing. The same applies to services, where Orr writes: Chinese airlines use e-ticketing to substitute for desk agents at least as aggressively as any mature-market airline. Telecommunications, financial services, and retail are all being challenged by “people lite” Internet-based business models from new competitors, which have already led them to substantially reduce hiring. In 2015, they will need to quietly cut back further.
  • He says that this will lead to another year of frustration for students, a record 7.36m of which graduated from China’s universities last year. Orr adds: A substantial proportion of new graduates will not find jobs that require a degree. Indeed, many will find what they learned and how they learned at university has done little to prepare them for the 2015 job market in China. Other than for an elite minority, starting salaries will be flat yet again, at levels less than the income level of a full-time taxi driver.
  • Then you have what he aptly calls the further “Detroisation” of certain regions and cities in China [these are the regions heavily dependent on highly polluting, oversupplied heavy industries such as steel, cement and some chemicals. Since the beginning of 2013, for instance, The Economist reports that in Hebei province alone, 18,000 polluting factories have been shut down.
  • Orr believes all of this will translate into lower consumer confidence and so lower growth in consumer spending [you also need to take into account the end of the “wealth effect” of the 2008-2013 economic stimulus programme).

Yes, I think that China has all the right plans in place to eventually become a service and consumption-driven economy.  Just look at what it has already achieved in the smartphones sector.

But that is the long term and does not mean that any of us can afford to sit back and say that everything will be more or less fine over the next few years.

Instead, the strain on both manufacturing, service jobs and thus consumer spending to me point in this direction: The potential for a devaluation of the Yuan in order to boost exports as a means of compensating for weaker growth at home.


Where Have All The Jobs Gone?


By John Richardson POLITICIANS everywhere know that their chances of staying in ...

Learn more

China Peak Steel And Chemicals Demand May Have Arrived


By John Richardson EVERYONE involved in the iron ore business must be very worri...

Learn more
More posts
Coronavirus, impact on the developing world and the scale of demand losses

By John Richardson ALL OF us are struggling to come to terms with a collapse in the global economy t...

Coronavirus, reshoring and the polyester industry: Good luck with that

By John Richardson POLITICIANS, not just including the Populist variety, are talking a lot about res...

Beware of the fragile nature of the oil and petrochemical price recovery

By John Richardson RECENT rises in oil and petrochemicals prices should not in my view be taken as a...

China petrochemical inventories build on what could be false hopes of a V-shaped rebound

By John Richardson AS PETROCHEMICALS storage space in China fills up on the hope that the country ca...

Further polyethylene rate cuts seem inevitable with no certainty on who will blink first

By John Richardson IT IS NOT just a razor-like focus on petrochemicals demand that will get you thro...

What petrochemical companies must do to adapt to a smaller coronavirus economy

By John Richardson PETROCHEMICAL companies can adapt to the coronavirus New Normal by running their ...

Coronavirus and the way forward: Forecasting micro surges in petrochemicals demand

By John Richardson THE MONTH of May is normally a low season for toluene di-isocyanate (TDI) demand ...

Southeast Asia polyolefins demand may fall by as much as during Asian Financial Crisis

By John Richardson HOW do you replace anywhere between 9% and 18% of GDP when it has virtually disap...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more