Oil markets have lost their price discovery role

Economic growth

SHARE THIS STORY

WTIvS&P Nov12.pngThe US spent $6bn on its presidential and congressional elections this year. Apart from expressing the will of the people, it may also prove valuable if it helps to highlight the danger of allowing wishful thinking to override factual evidence on the ground.

One example of this failing was last Monday’s forecast by the highly-respected US political commentator Peggy Noonan that “I think its this: a Romney win“. Noonan is one of the blog’s favourite political commentators. But she made the mistake of ignoring the data analysis undertaken by statistician Nate Silver – who correctly forecast the margin of Obama’s win, and every single one of the results in the 50 states.

Unfortunately, a similar gap has opened up in the conduct of economic policy. Most central bankers now assume that constant growth is normal. And so like Noonan, they ignore any statistical evidence suggesting they are wrong, even from a central bank with real experience of the issue, the Bank of Japan. It has just produced another detailed paper explaining how ageing populations reduce economic growth.

The result is that wishful thinking now dominates central bank policy, as the blog will discuss today in a presentation*, at our Berlin conference. The chart above highlights the problem. It shows how prices for Brent (red line), WTI (green) and the US S&P 500 Index (blue) have become highly correlated since their liquidity programmes began in October 2008:

• Historically, higher oil prices were seen as bad for the economy
• The S&P 500 would therefore fall when oil rose, and vice versa
• Now however, fundamentals of supply/demand are irrelevant
• Instead, asset prices are all moving together in correlation

The main reason for this is the mistaken but understandable fear of pension funds that these programmes will lead to higher inflation and a lower value for the US$. They therefore see oil as a ‘store of value’, and so their cash overwhelms the smaller flows of physical oil markets.

In turn, this means that no single market now knows what it is supposed to be pricing. Oil markets now account for 5% of global GDP, which has always led to recession in the past. And yet there is absolutely no fundamental reason for today’s high prices. Inventories remain high, supply is expanding rapidly, and demand is falling.

When Peggy Noonan had to face up to her mistake on Wednesday morning, it was only her personal pride that was hurt. Unfortunately for all of us, the central banks’ myopia is creating far more dangerous and longer-lasting consequences for the global economy.

* Please click here to download the presentation

PREVIOUS POST

IMF warns on recession risk as Political, Social worries rise

12/11/2012

When the economy is running well, most people tend to get on with their lives. T...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Polyester markets head for crisis as cotton prices crash

14/11/2012

Cotton prices, as the chart shows, have returned to the 50c-70c/lb range that ha...

Learn more
More posts
Smallpox was the first vaccination to change the world – now we have a new opportunity to improve our lives
03/04/2021

Chart 1: Increased life expectancy led to a dramatic increase in GDP/capita The pandemic has reminde...

Read
COP 26 set to accelerate development of the 15-minute city
28/03/2021

One of the good things to happen in the pandemic over the past year is that ‘cooking has becom...

Read
China’s dual circulation policy aims to reduce debt reliance
14/03/2021

Every now and then, people wake up to the fact that debt is only good news when it adds to growth. O...

Read
UK set to take hard line on EU trade under David Frost
21/02/2021

The Brexit debate has always been about politics, not economics.  So it was no surprise that Decemb...

Read
EU focuses on a sustainable and circular plastics system
31/01/2021

“The challenges posed by plastics are to a large extent due to the fact that our production and co...

Read
Businesses face “biggest imposition of red tape in 50 years” as Brexit begins
03/01/2021

Most companies had closed when the new EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) was finally annou...

Read
Your A to Z Guide to the reality of Brexit after 31 December
29/11/2020

(Picture credit Shutterstock) A.  Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty set out the rules for leaving ...

Read
Chemistry & the Economy webinar on Thursday
10/11/2020

Please join me for the next ACS Chemicals & Economy webinar on Thursday, at 2pm Eastern Standard...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more