US homeownership equals all-time low as demand patterns change

Consumer demand

SHARE THIS STORY

US housing Sept16

It is is 10 years since the US subprime bubble began to burst, with disastrous results for the US and global economy.

The US Federal Reserve  had created the bubble in the belief that higher house prices would boost the economy.  It then made a bad situation into a disaster by refusing to accept that a bubble existed:

  Alan Greenspan, then Chairman of the Fed, told Congress in June 2005, at the height of the bubble:
“Although we certainly cannot rule out home price declines, especially in some local markets, these declines, were they to occur, likely would not have substantial macroeconomic implications
  Ben Bernanke, Greenspan’s successor as Fed chairman, then continued to argue that there was “no housing bubble to go bust

Yet US housing starts have never returned to the 2.0 – 2.3 million/year level seen between 2003 – 2006.  Last month, they were just half this level at 1.1 million/year.

The Fed’s failure has had important implications for US housing policy.  Both President Clinton and President Bush had focused on increasing home-ownership.  When Clinton’s 67.5% target was reached in 2000, Bush was keen to achieve higher levels.  But instead, as the chart shows, ownership peaked at 69.2% in 2005, and then began to collapse as the subprime bubble burst:

  It is now back at 62.9%, equal to the lowest level seen since records began in 1965
  The trend is clearly downwards, and so it seems likely the rate will fall to new lows later this year

US housing Sept16aHousing therefore represents an excellent example of the importance of demographics in driving demand, rather than monetary policy.  Since 2008, the Fed has taken interest rates to their lowest level in history, and printed money at an extraordinary rate, in order to create consumer demand.

But it has completely failed to restore the housing market to its former levels, for the simple reason that demand patterns are driven by issues of lifestyle and affordability – rather than just interest rates.  As the second chart shows, housing starts have not only halved since their 2006 peak, but the type of homes being built has changed quite dramatically:

  Today’s Millennials are not following their Boomer parents in wanting to buy McMansions in the suburbs
  They have much higher debt levels due to the cost of tuition fees, and they are having fewer children
  The recovery in house prices fostered by Fed policy has also reduced their ability to buy single homes
  The Boomers themselves are also no longer so keen on suburban living, and prefer to be town/city-based
  As a result, over a third of all new homes are multi-unit – twice the level seen in the boom years of 1990 – 2007

A new study from Corelogic confirms that affordability issues also impact existing homeowners:

Homeowners making moves out of state are increasingly selling out of expensive markets like California, where price escalation is steep, and buying into lower-cost markets such as Texas and Arizona.  Overall between 2000 and 2015, 2.5 home sellers left California for every out-of-state buyer coming into the state”.

The US housing market thus confirms the profound changes taking place in Western demand patterns. It also highlights the risk of believing that the Fed is able to guide developments in its preferred direction.  Or, indeed, of believing that the Fed has a good grasp of what is actually happening in the real economy.

PREVIOUS POST

World Aromatics Conference focuses on key industry challenges

27/09/2016

The 15th World Aromatics & Derivatives Conference take place in Vienna on 2...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Hope is not a strategy

30/09/2016

Chemical companies face difficult times if they cling to the hope that current c...

Learn more
More posts
The Top 5 pandemic paradigm shifts
28/06/2020

The Covid-19 pandemic has accelerated the fundamental changes which were already underway in global ...

Read
Hertz goes bankrupt as non-essential consumer demand disappears
24/05/2020

The US Federal Reserve has now spent $7tn bailing out Wall Street. But it couldn’t save the 10...

Read
Smartphone sales head into decline as affordability becomes key
10/05/2020

The smartphone sales decline accelerated in Q1, as Strategy Analytics report: “Global smartpho...

Read
China’s plastic ban and recycling launch marks end of ‘business as usual’ for plastics industry
26/01/2020

Paradigm shifts start slowly at first, and it is easy to miss them. But then one day, they suddenly ...

Read
Automakers face stiff headwinds in big emerging markets
19/01/2020

Brazil, Russia, India and China disappoint as manufacturers face investment demands of EVs © Bloomb...

Read
Portugal shows the way to climate neutrality by 2050
24/11/2019

“If you don’t know where you are going, any road will do”. The Irish proverb’...

Read
The next billion phone users will be buying $10 smart feature phones, not $1000 iPhones
10/11/2019

Smartphone sales plateaued in Q3, down 9% since Q3 2017’s peak of 1.55bn, as the chart shows....

Read
Companies ignore the Perennials 55+ generation at their peril
13/10/2019

Nearly a third of the the world’s High Income population are now in the Perennials 55+ generat...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more