Global PP market divide may rebalance painfully

ICIS, Uncategorised

They say a picture is worth a thousand words, but I can prove the one here is worth 1,034.

How so? Because my colleague John Richardson wrote that many in his excellent 5 September blog on the yawning gap between NE Asia and US polypropylene (PP) prices, and the reasons behind that.

Without knowing those markets, you can infer a couple of important points just by analysing the graph.

  • These two regions’ PP prices have tended to track each other, until 2021.
  • Something major must be impeding that historical relationship.

Of course, that “something major” is disjointed shipping situation that has global container shipments in particular out of whack. A year ago, container shipping from China to the US West Coast cost under $4,000/container. It now can cost almost $20,000/container, and that is if you can find a container. Demand for PP is weak across Asia, keeping resin prices low, but elevated container shipping prices that can add upwards to $1,000/tonne to the PP price – let alone lead times that now can be measured in months and not weeks – are deterring acting on what is an open arbitrage window.

Still, some are being brave enough to transact on this opportunity. US PP imports rose by 89% in the first half of this year compared with the same timeframe in 2020, according to the ICIS Supply and Demand Database. Where did those imports come from? Asia, as South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan were the top sources of that imported PP.

Perspective remains key here, as the imports amount to a drop in the bucket compared with US domestic production, as Chemical Data, part of ICIS, noted in its August Monthly Petrochemical & Plastics Analysis. While US imports hit a record 155m lbs (70,308 tonnes) in June, US domestic PP production in the same month was 1.688bn lbs (765,672 tonnes). But in a market as tight as US PP has been this year amid resilient demand from consumer durable and non-durable goods sectors, every tonne added to the supply heap matters.

The question now though is, how long will this Asia-to-US opportunity exist? Unfortunately, the question is fraught with possible negative outcomes.

If consumer demand remains resilient – and as steadily strong as it has been over the past year, who is to say it will not – then it is likely container shipping prices will continue to escalate. If yesterday’s and today’s lower prices did not destroy demand, why should tomorrow’s higher price? At some point the shipping price would rise to where the arbitrage is no longer workable economically, which could escalate US domestic PP prices further amid tightening supply, creating demand destruction, while depressing Asia PP prices further and leading to supply destruction there. Not a good outcome for either continent.

If consumer demand wanes due to the end of government stimulus programmes and decreased economic activity, that would help rebalance the container shipping market, but at what cost? The collateral damage would be slow-to-no economic growth, or more likely recessionary conditions that benefit neither consumers nor PP markets. Again, that is not an outcome that benefits many.

Of course, we could have a wave of new containers and container ships arrive on the scene to support resilient demand and normalise PP markets global supply, but that feels rather optimistic and simplistic a solution. Adding more ships does not also mean adding more ports to load and unload materials and goods; in fact, it would exacerbate the current backlogs at the ports.

Unfortunately, extreme situations such as the wide disparities among regional PP market situations do not glide into a calm resolution but instead change with a resounding development. Here’s hoping that development is of the positive variety, but be prepared for it to be the other way around.

Disclaimer: The views in this blogpost should in no shape or form be taken as actual forecasts and are my personal views only.

PREVIOUS POST

Market danger set to lurk in the Gulf

25/08/2021

Time to keep a watchful eye on the Gulf of Mexico. Apropos of the approaching pe...

Learn more
More posts
Market danger set to lurk in the Gulf
25/08/2021

Time to keep a watchful eye on the Gulf of Mexico. Apropos of the approaching peak of the Atlantic h...

Read
Chemical, resin plants may be hurricane-ready, but markets are not
29/06/2021

Forecasters of this year’s hurricane season expect above-normal activity, and so far that seems on...

Read
Logistics making inflation worries more than transitory
15/06/2021

How bad are things on the logistics front? A COVID-19 outbreak at the Port of Yantian in China is ca...

Read
Fundamentals will matter to plastics markets again, and be careful when they do
18/05/2021

Supply tightness in key commodities such as chemicals, polymers, lumber and steel has been a major s...

Read
Can consumers afford the price rises commodities are portending?
09/04/2021

Get ready to open your wallets a bit more. Whether you are in the chemical business, the services in...

Read
End result of Biden’s ambitious infrastructure proposal may underwhelm
01/04/2021

Reinvestment in infrastructure has finally made it to centre stage of US political discussions, but ...

Read
Immense challenges facing chemical, polymer procurers
12/03/2021

Mid-February’s prolonged freeze on the Texas-Louisiana coast has juiced up market commentary as mu...

Read
Great news buried beneath recent vaccine headlines
03/02/2021

With news bubbling up about coronavirus variants, here is a variant message of my own: Look past the...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more