ICIS View: Groningen residents’ gain is Europe’s loss



As the bill to cut production from the Netherlands’ giant Groningen field makes its way through the Dutch halls of power, the challenges of implementing it are becoming increasingly apparent.

Traders want greater clarity on how fast production will fall, particularly in the coming gas year.

Big industrial customers forced to convert infrastructure for use with imported gas want to know who will foot the bill.

Storage operators feeling the pressure of already narrow margins want guarantees of compensation if they have to take on some of Groningen’s swing-supplier role.

They should get some answers in the coming weeks, but they may not like what they hear.

Crunch time

This Thursday, parliament will grill economic affairs minister Eric Wiebes on his bill, which proposes to slash production from its current permitted level of around 20 billion cubic meters (bcm) to 12bcm by 2022 and zero by 2030, in order to reduce the risk of earthquakes in the region.

The debate is scheduled to begin at 14:45 Amsterdam time and could continue until as late as 22:00, parliamentary spokesman Edward Donraadt told ICIS on Tuesday – far longer than most debates.
This will be followed by a parliamentary vote on the bill a week later – most likely on 12 June, according to Donraadt.

The debate and the results of the vote will inform the final production plan for Groningen over the next gas year, which starts on 1 October. The minister has previously said he would publish the plan in June.

Pressure building

The backdrop for this flurry of parliamentary activity is the publication on Monday of the Council of State’s advice to the minister on the bill.

The council is the Netherlands’ highest administrative court, and ministers traditionally seek its advice before sending legislation to parliament, though they are not bound to heed it.

For the market, the court’s key message was that “safety for local residents takes precedence above the societal importance of security of supply”.

The minister had previously defended security of supply, arguing that lives could be at risk if flows of gas for electricity, heat and cooking are interrupted. But the council said he had “inflated” its importance.

Given that it is the biggest onshore gas field in Europe, the closure of Groningen already presents a major challenge to the make-up of regional supply, which will increasingly rely on Norway, Russia and LNG for imports.

In privileging the safety of Groningen residents, this latest advice puts pressure on the minister to cut supply even faster than initially planned.

MPs who owe their jobs to the public have every incentive to take the same line in Thursday’s marathon debate.

Their primary concern is rightly the safety of the Dutch public, but they should know that what they decide will affect markets across the whole continent.



LNG Markets Analysis Spot LNG shows strong gains for June


Spot LNG markers for June-delivery cargoes gained 10% on the month and 40% on th...

Learn more

LNG Markets Analysis Soaring Asia widens spread to Europe


Spot LNG prices for East Asia soared during the four weeks from mid-May to mid-J...

Learn more
More posts
Oil crash closes gap to spot LNG

Spot LNG held largely stable around $3.00/MMBtu levels from mid-February to mid-March, but a huge cr...

Spot LNG falls below $3 after mild winter, virus

Spot LNG prices have dropped to record lows under $3.00/MMBtu after a mild winter combined with the ...

US LNG projects advance as spot remains low

Global LNG prices remained soft in the four weeks to mid-January as US export projects continued to ...

Spot LNG prices for January slide as US plants begin

Spot LNG prices over the past four weeks for January 2020 cargoes to Asia averaged $5.515/MMBtu, fal...

Asian LNG softens on mild weather, strong supply

Spot LNG prices in east Asia softened over the past four weeks on indications of mild weather for th...

Spot bulls challenge LNG supply bears

Cuts to Dutch gas production, French nuclear troubles and a court case impacting Russian pipe flows ...

Freeport LNG set for first cargo, storage talk grows

The 5.0 million tonnes per annum (mtpa) US Freeport LNG train one was getting ready to load its firs...

LNG spreads tighten, Gulf braces for storm

Spot LNG prices held below $5.00/MMBtu in the four weeks from mid-June to mid-July on the back of co...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more