Ballast bonuses sink shipping activity

Admin

SHARE THIS STORY

The cancellation of two planned LNG vessel charters in Europe this week shows that it’s becoming harder and harder to get hold of an LNG carrier at the right price in the Atlantic Basin.

Danish energy company DONG and Swiss trader Glencore were both in discussions with ship owners about chartering vessels for reloads in early October. Reloading LNG is a method of exporting LNG from a terminal that normally imports the commodity, and is Europe’s principal means of making LNG sales. This week, both prospective vessel fixtures for these reloads were put on hold.

The failed charters are in good company. An attempt by Vitol to find a vessel for a Zeebrugge reload on 3-6 October has gone quiet. Market sources say that the LNG volumes have been sold onto a portfolio player with its own ships. In fact, the only successful shipping fixture in the Atlantic in recent weeks has been the 170,200 cubic metre Veliky Novgorod is fixed to Shell to lift from Nigeria. This is in contrast to a flurry of fixtures in the Pacific Basin.

Disparity

Why are ships getting fixed in one basin and not the other? Daily charter rates are not too different. According to ICIS assessments, costs for a ship with cold tanks in the Atlantic are $5,000/day more than in the Pacific.

No, it is not the headline rate that is the problem, but the ballast bonus. This lump sum figure, also known as round-trip economics, pays for the ship owner to reposition the vessel in a lucrative spot after having deposited the LNG volumes. It also covers fuel, hire and canal fees during the voyage and often the return leg. Considering Suez Canal passage can be upwards of $200,000, ballast bonus poses a significant cost to charterers.

With fewer vessels available in the Atlantic than in the Pacific, ship owners feel able to ask for full round-trip economics in one basin, but not in the other. This is creating a mismatch of price expectations in the Atlantic between ship owners and prospective charterers, and a dearth of fixtures.

Rebalance

So when will ship owners catch up to the market and stop demanding a ballast bonus? It will take the return not of more ships to the Atlantic Basin, but more ship owners to bring down the ballast bonus. There are already a number of Cool Pool vessels open in the Atlantic, but these are all operated by one service – carrier pooler Cool Pool. The Atlantic needs different operators to compete with one another on price.

Until then, traders in search of a vessel do better to sub-charter from a portfolio player like ENGIE, Gas Natural or Shell, whose large fleets enable the portfolio player to optimise their vessels’ positioning and skip the ballast bonus.

PREVIOUS POST

A crazy week in UK power. But will the madness return this winter?

22/09/2016

In recent days, UK power has been a crazy energy market to trade in. Late in the...

Learn more
NEXT POST

2016 - for LNG it was the year that wasn’t

24/10/2016

The long-awaited surge of new global LNG production has not led to the widely-ex...

Learn more
More posts
Clock is ticking on MiFID II
02/02/2017

Time is running out for energy companies that have to work out if they will be included or exempted ...

Read
No alternative: Europe’s low-carbon energy transition will come of age in 2017
25/01/2017

“Alternative energy”. Is that still a common phrase? In some quarters, it is. In a recent New Yo...

Read
Should the EU get tough on the gas network codes?
10/11/2016

Following the recent publication of the EU Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators’ (ACER)...

Read
2016 – for LNG it was the year that wasn’t
24/10/2016

The long-awaited surge of new global LNG production has not led to the widely-expected and sustained...

Read
A crazy week in UK power. But will the madness return this winter?
22/09/2016

In recent days, UK power has been a crazy energy market to trade in. Late in the day on 14 September...

Read
What’s in a name? That which we call a Bulgarian hub
13/09/2016

Bulgaria and the European Commission have recently been announcing, with much fanfare, the country i...

Read
This winter it really is about the weather
02/09/2016

The cliche about weather driving energy prices, in particular on European gas and Asian LNG, is just...

Read
Time for change: The expiry of Gazprom contracts in eastern Europe
31/08/2016

While all eyes are turned to Russia’s natural gas pipeline projects – Nord Stream II, TurkStream...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more