The flawed “science” of forecasting

Business, China, Economics, Markets, Polyolefins

Maybe I’ve been to too many conferences this year, and indeed over the last decade, and have seen too many forecasts go wrong.

Call me cynical, or plain wrong, but………..……the key to success in a chemical company planning department or in a consulting firm might be to produce numbers with decimal points in order to give the impression that you have been precise with your calculations.

Round numbers lack the feeling of credibility because the world is seen, quite rightly, as a complex place. The temptation could therefore be to add a 0.1 or a 0.3 if your calculations have actually generated, say, an estimate of exactly 10% demand growth for polyethylene in China in 2007.

It’s not just a case of the suspiciously nearly always un-round numbers that give cause for concern.

In the ten years I’ve been covering this industry I haven’t once heard somebody ask for details of the assumptions behind the numbers presented by consultants and chemical companies during conferences and seminars. This is extraordinary when you consider I have seen almost as many PowerPoint slides as there are demand and price forecasts that have been proved wrong.

But maybe all this takes place behind closed doors during question and answer sessions or in rigorous cross-checking of every internally and externally produced report that lands on the desks of project planners.

I doubt this very much, firstly because of the volume of numbers that need to be fed into any model for predicting the profitability of a new project. Any one individual might have a view on polycarbonate demand growth in China and India, but Vietnam?

Leaving Vietnam up to the experts as it’s only a relatively small country and won’t make that much difference to the overall global supply and demand balances might be the temptation.

But if enough Vietnams are added together, you might end up with an error significantly bigger than a few decimal points added to round numbers for the sake of authenticity.

Secondly, company executives quite often want their hunches confirmed and therefore look for supporting rather contradictory evidence. In other words, they will happily swallow any number (preferably not a whole number) which helps them get a proposal past their board of directors.

As I said, this might all be far too cynical, grossly unfair and ill-informed. But can you honestly say you have challenged every single number that’s come across your desk?

And why, if the “science” of forecasting is indeed a science, do company research departments and consultants keep getting it wrong time and time again?

PREVIOUS POST

Can polymers rescue the Mile High Club?

18/11/2007

Maybe Singapore airlines has got the wrong end of the stick by trying to ban fir...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Asian biofuels face a big crisis

21/11/2007

After all the optimism, all the hype and a lot of investors’ money, the in...

Learn more
More posts
Omicron, petchems and the developing world: we might get lucky this time, but maybe not next time
02/12/2021

By John Richardson UNTIL ALL of us are adequately vaccinated none of us are sufficiently protected i...

Read
Benzene, the need for a new global Industrial Revolution and the big challenges that lie ahead
30/11/2021

By John Richardson THE CHART BELOW shows that 60% of global benzene production in 2021-2040 is forec...

Read
Global polypropylene could also move from inflation to deflation in Q1 next year
23/11/2021

By John Richardson WE ALL NEED TO ASK ourselves whether the global patterns in polyethylene (PE) and...

Read
Global polyethylene could move from inflation to deflation by as early as Q1 2022
22/11/2021

By John Richardson THE BALTIC DRY INDEX, one of the excellent barometers of overall economic activit...

Read
As China coal shortages end, polyolefins margins reach historic lows on oversupply
17/11/2021

By John Richardson AGAIN, DON’T say I didn’t tell you. In my 11 October blog post, having talked...

Read
Dip in Chinese PP exports only temporary with Q1 2022 resurgence looking likely
15/11/2021

By John Richardson TRADE DATA when combined with price assessments, supply and demand estimates and ...

Read
Global polyethylene supply could lengthen, becoming a buyers’ market, sooner than many people think
12/11/2021

By John Richardson RARELY, IF EVER, have events felt so bafflingly complex in the global polyethylen...

Read
China could either see net imports of 63m tonnes in 2021-2031 or net exports of 18m tonnes!
09/11/2021

By John Richardson CONFUSED BY the above chart? Once again I certainly hope so, provided confusion i...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more