China Stock Markets Were Never A “Magic Pill”

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics

By John Richardson

ChinanewstocksTHE good news is that only an estimated one in 15 Chinese people at the very most trade in stocks compared with more than half of Americans.

But the bad news is that this one in 15 is higher than it was around a year ago, when China’s stock markets first began to rally. Over the last few months alone, around 20 million new accounts have been opened on each of the country’s two exchanges – Shanghai and Shenzhen.

The further bad news is that three quarters of activity on these exchanges is in individual accounts – a much higher proportion then in Western markets, which tend to be dominated by institutional investors.

This means that if  the stock market bubble has burst, there will be a considerable number of middle class Chinese who will be an awful lot poorer than they were a couple of weeks ago.

This already includes He Wuhong, a Beijing middle school teacher and mother of a toddler. She and her husband invested nearly all of their $65,000 in savings in China’s stock market in late April and early May, only to see their account’s value fall by almost half, according to the New York Times:

And here is some even more bad news from Barron’s, the investment news service:

If the stock market keeps falling, as it did in 2007-08 when the Shanghai Composite dropped almost 70% and then remained there for six years, China’s investing public, the many corporations that have taken to speculating in the stock market on the side, and the banks that extended collateralised loans to insiders, will be in a world of hurt. This would only add to the capital destruction that impends in China’s wobbly real estate market.

But, as I said, this is still only one in 15 people in China. And as Barron’s once again wrote:

Year to date, funds raised from equity issues have totalled RMB2.8 trillion ($452 billion). That compares with loan volume of RMB52.6 trillion and RMB6.9 trillion in corporate bond issuance.

Here are two myths about China’s stock markets which you, as a result, must dismiss:

  1. That surging equities can create a new broad-based “wealth effect” to replace the end of  the credit-fuelled wealth effect of 2009-2013.
  2. That the rise in local stock markets will allow heavily indebted state-owned enterprises to recapitalise themselves, with IPOs providing a fantastic source of funding to China’s more innovative private companies.

What everyone needs to instead understand is that booming equity markets were never going to be a “magic pill” that would solve China’s economic problems.

So, even if the many government measures designed to engineer a recovery in local stock markets work, this will not change anything.

And there is in fact no single magic pill that can solve China’s economic problems.

What instead lies ahead for China is a long, hard slog of economic reforms. This will mean low single-digit GDP growth for the next few years at least.

As more and more people wake up to this reality, this can only mean an increase in global financial and oil market volatility and weakness.

This new understanding about China will combine with the realisation that EU politicians have got it completely wrong over Greece – and over the Eurozone as a whole.

Put these two events together and have the equivalent of an new Lehman Bros-type, albeit perhaps on a slower fuse.

The New Normal is well and truly here.

PREVIOUS POST

Greece No Vote Exposes Eurozone Flaws

06/07/2015

By John Richardson A MAN who is drunk on somebody else’s money attempts to cro...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Oil Markets Return To Supply And Demand Realities

08/07/2015

By John Richardson ONLY a couple of months ago a lot of people seemed confident ...

Learn more
More posts
Coronavirus, impact on the developing world and the scale of demand losses
29/05/2020

By John Richardson ALL OF us are struggling to come to terms with a collapse in the global economy t...

Read
Coronavirus, reshoring and the polyester industry: Good luck with that
27/05/2020

By John Richardson POLITICIANS, not just including the Populist variety, are talking a lot about res...

Read
Beware of the fragile nature of the oil and petrochemical price recovery
22/05/2020

By John Richardson RECENT rises in oil and petrochemicals prices should not in my view be taken as a...

Read
China petrochemical inventories build on what could be false hopes of a V-shaped rebound
19/05/2020

By John Richardson AS PETROCHEMICALS storage space in China fills up on the hope that the country ca...

Read
Further polyethylene rate cuts seem inevitable with no certainty on who will blink first
18/05/2020

By John Richardson IT IS NOT just a razor-like focus on petrochemicals demand that will get you thro...

Read
What petrochemical companies must do to adapt to a smaller coronavirus economy
15/05/2020

By John Richardson PETROCHEMICAL companies can adapt to the coronavirus New Normal by running their ...

Read
Coronavirus and the way forward: Forecasting micro surges in petrochemicals demand
11/05/2020

By John Richardson THE MONTH of May is normally a low season for toluene di-isocyanate (TDI) demand ...

Read
Southeast Asia polyolefins demand may fall by as much as during Asian Financial Crisis
08/05/2020

By John Richardson HOW do you replace anywhere between 9% and 18% of GDP when it has virtually disap...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more