Don’t Bet On A Post-Lunar New Year Rebound

Business, China, Company Strategy, Oil & Gas, Olefins, Polyolefins

China30Jan2

 

By John Richardson

THERE is a very risky theory that I have picked up in my conversations with Asian polyolefin industry players over the past few days:

Strong underlying demand growth in China, low stock levels held by the country’s plastic converters and a stabilisation of oil prices will result in a firm recovery in demand after the Lunar New Year.

(Most of China will, by the way, be on leave from 18 February to 24 February).

Let’s first of all tackle the “strong underlying demand growth” argument.

Everyone keeps on saying that China’s demand in volume terms is far bigger than it was a decade ago. Growth of, say, 3-4% in 2015 will thus be from a much-bigger consumption base than ten years ago.

In the Old Normal world this is kind of analysis was, more or less, all that you needed. But we are no longer in the Old Normal world.

China is taking shock medicine designed to revive a very sick patient, or as veteran metals analyst Simon Hunt describes it, “the government knows that they have to clean house”.

Simon, who is UK-based, is in China at the moment. In his interim report on his latest visit he writes the following:

  • As a consequence of “cleaning house” there will be bankruptcies of manufacturing, real estate and finance companies.
  •  “A couple of years ago we spoke about a huge bubble in trade finance or the misuse of Letters of Credit.” The numbers involved could be equivalent of 25% of GDP, he warned.
  • He sees the development of the speculation game as taking place in three stages. First, metals smelters started using LCs to speculate in physical and futures markets. Next, they started using LCs to arbitrage interest rates. And finally, companies totally unconnected to commodities, such as real estate and textile companies entered the game. They bought metals just to get their hands on LCs so they could speculate elsewhere. We have seen a similar pattern in PE.
  • “What drove the bubble starting from around 2005 was the sense, whether real or not, that the world was as the start of a commodities Supercycle,” he added.

Far too many people believed in this commodities Supercycle, when all the evidence told us that it was based on a unsustainable increase in credit  in China.

In response to this mistake,people built or planned too many polyolefins plants, copper plants and steel mills etc.

Speculation in global financial and commodity markets also took place on this mistaken analysis.

This is why I still firmly believe that as credit is withdrawn in China, the global effects will be much bigger than US sub-prime.

We can see this today in metals pricing.

Yesterday, for example, the prices of copper and iron ore fell to five-and-half-year lows.

“For several years after 2000, an apparently relentless rise in Chinese metal consumption raised expectations of a ‘Supercycle’ that would juice up prices indefinitely,” wrote the Wall Street Journal, in the same article to which I have just linked.

“Signs are mounting, though, that Chinese demand is now a less reliable prop for metals prices.”

And where copper and iron ore have gone so, of course, has oil.

“Inventories of US crude were already at record highs for the week ended January 23, according to government data issued on Wednesday. Last week’s build alone was almost 9 million barrels, taking stockpiles to nearly 407 million, the highest level since the government began keeping such records in 1982,” wrote Reuters in this article, which was also published yesterday.

Also see my post from last Friday on crude.

This is what I instead think is going to happen after the LNY:

  • The oil price could well fall to new lows and is likely to stay very volatile within a lower range.
  • Meanwhile, many processors, distributors and traders will continue to struggle to source credit. I can only see this struggle getting worse as reforms accelerate.
  • Local banks will be increasingly reluctant to lend money because of concerns over bankruptcies. The snowball will gather more downhill momentum.
  • This  means that, regardless of today’s stock levels, polyolefin buying patterns will remain “hand to mouth”.

What goes for polyolefins will obviously also go for many other chemicals and polymers.

This is the beginning of a long and difficult reform process that will be completed. There are surely no doubts about that now.

Only when reforms have finished – and this will take several more years – will we really understand what “underlying demand growth” in China actually amounts to.

PREVIOUS POST

China Versus The EU: What A Contrast

29/01/2015

By John Richardson IT is worth comparing what is happening in China today with w...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Friday's Oil-Price Surge: Here Is The Right Context

02/02/2015

By John Richardson THE right historical context is crucial if you want to gain a...

Learn more
More posts
Global PVC demand could fall by 1.1m tonnes as coronavirus crisis becomes global
26/02/2020

By John Richardson YOU CANNOT stimulate economic activity when factories and offices need to be shut...

Read
China polyethylene imports could be 3m tonnes lower as economy seizes up
24/02/2020

By John Richardson IT IS TIME for crisis planning, I am afraid, as a result of the World Health Orga...

Read
Rescue of major conglomerate, struggling SMEs raise risks for China and global economies
20/02/2020

The most important issue here remains the human cost of the coronavirus outbreak. My thoughts and ho...

Read
Global polyethylene demand in 2020 at risk of 2.4m decline because of coronavirus
19/02/2020

By John Richardson I AM a bit confused this morning following some excitement about the Chinese deci...

Read
Coronavirus: Global polypropylene demand in 2020 could fall by 2.6m tonnes over last year
17/02/2020

By John Richardson SOME GOOD news might be that official Chinese state media announced that the numb...

Read
Coronavirus threatens 2.9m tonnes of China PP demand as uncertainties increase
14/02/2020

By John Richardson THE RUMOURS travelled around my contacts, and I am sure many of your contacts, fo...

Read
More than 3m tonnes of Chinese polyethylene demand at risk from coronavirus
08/02/2020

    By John Richardson THE GOOD news is that medical experts believe the novel coronavirus...

Read
Coronavirus: Global polyester chain faces major production cuts, shortages and cost increases
07/02/2020

By John Richardson A GREAT example of the extent to which global supply chains are exposed to China ...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more