Please Plan Now For A Yuan Devaluation

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics


By John Richardson

IF YOU haven’t already planned for the possibility of a substantial drop in the value of China’s Yuan then you have no more time to lose.

I suggest every chemicals company that finds itself in this situation should get down to work immediately. The hard questions about why nobody in your company picked up the warning signs – which were flashing amber as early as May 2013 – should be asked later on.

For me these warning signs started flashing red in the second half of 2014 when it became clear that China’s growth was slowing. I warned that the government had long set three main priorities – jobs, jobs and jobs – and that employment was under threat as a result of economic rebalancing. I felt that a Yuan devaluation might be one means of protecting jobs.

Then in November, James Gruber, a Melbourne Australia-based financial journalist and fund manager, with whom I work closely, published this important research note on how the unwinding of China’s “carry trade” * could by itself force a Yuan devaluation (*see my footnote for a definition of this carry trade).

At that time he had the foresight to warn that capital outflows, on a slowing Chinese economy and a stronger US dollar, could be the mechanism behind the winding of these carry trades.

And this is how he saw the future playing out:

Initially, we suspect that China would try to defend the currency by liquidating foreign exchange reserves. That would risk a deflationary spiral, however. It would shrink money supply, reduce credit growth, leading to falling asset prices and further capital flight.

Remember that this strategy was pursued initially by the Asian tigers in 1997. It was abandoned as it proved too painful. Devaluation was eventually favoured and the Tiger currencies declined close to 60% on average.

If capital flight were to occur, we believe China would eventually follow the less-painful route of devaluation too.

Official figures, which were released in January, showed that in Q4 of last year capital flight had risen to $91 billion compared with $56.7 billion in Q3.

And then came last week’s release of data on China’s imports, exports, consumer price inflation, producer price deflation and employment for January.

Wind forward to this week when:

  • “My personal view is that the domestic and foreign situation looks more and more like the Asian Financial Crisis,” said Guan Tao, director of international settlements at China’s State Administration of Foreign Exchange. The 1997-1998 Asian Financial Crisis was triggered by capital flight from Thailand, Indonesia and South Korea. This led to currency devaluations and a region-wide banking crisis.
  • “We can sense the atmosphere of the Asian Financial Crisis is getting closer and closer to us,” added Guan, who identified capital flight on a weakening property market as the biggest risk for China.
  • Bank of America (BOA) warned that Yuan depreciation is one of the few tools left for China to ensure it gets a good share of global demand and meets its growth and jobs targets.
  • The ripple effects in China, and globally, of this happening would be substantial, added the BOA. (See my post from February 2014]. These ripple effects would include a further fall in commodity prices, the unwinding of the carry trade, more downward pressure on Chinese property prices and a resulting rise in bad debt, said the bank.
  • Whilst banks and property companies with heavy foreign debts would suffer from a devaluation, China’s exporters would benefit, said the BOA [These would include Chinese chemicals companies, which, thanks to the 2008-2013 stimulus package, have lots of spare production to dispose of].
  • “There is more cash betting against the yuan than there has been for 10 months, according to recent survey data from Reuters on investors’ positions in the dollar against Asian currencies. Many investors say the currency is still too strong given China’s declining growth rate, falling inflation—which is at a five-year low—and dismal economic data,” wrote the Wall Street Journal. 

The worrying thing for me is that China, whilst it might well have the right long term vision, looks as if it could well lose control of the immediate crisis.


*Definition of the carry trade: Traders have been borrowing in developed-market currencies with very low interest rates, predominantly in US dollars, and buying Yuan-denominated assets with much higher yields. This has enable to make money through “interest-rate arbitrage” – higher deposit rates in China compared with overseas. They have also made money from steady Yuan appreciation. Here is how this worked: You borrowed in US dollars and converted to Yuan. By the time you had to repay your US dollar loan, the Yuan was stronger and so you made a currency gain.


China By Itself Is Not A Strategy


By John Richardson SOMETIMES a bit of data is worth many thousands of words – ...

Learn more

Where Have All The Jobs Gone?


By John Richardson POLITICIANS everywhere know that their chances of staying in ...

Learn more
More posts
Global polyethylene oversupply, the highest in 19 years, hasn’t gone away

By John Richardson BRENT crude futures surged by 80% during the second quarter and enjoyed their bes...

China could be in complete polypropylene self-sufficiency by 2022

By John Richardson SORRY to labour the point but this comes from a genuine concern for the readers o...

Asian polyethylene price recovery faces multiple challenges

By John Richardson THERE are reports of significant cuts in Middle East polyethylene (PE) operating ...

China’s long-term ambition for paraxylene self-sufficiency seems close to being realised

On Friday, I examined how China’s paraxylene (PX) net imports could fall to as little 8m tonne...

China’s big declines in 2020 PX and PP imports: the impact on its major trading partners

By John Richardson CHINA’S refineries and petrochemicals plants came roaring back to almost fu...

Paraxylene demand collapses as higher China production threatens 6m tonne fall in imports

By John Richardson DON’T SAY I didn’t tell you that a decline in stock markets would happen. The...

Coronavirus will severely damage the developing world unless we take the right steps

By John Richardson IT IS a fantastic achievement. “Over the last 25 years, more than a billion peo...

Main Street versus Wall Street and the crisis in the developing world

By John Richardson RISING equity and oil markets do not necessarily point to a V-shaped recovery. I ...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more

Uncover exclusive industry upates from ICIS

Interested to uncover more articles related to this topic? Explore additional news, insights and intelligence, tailored to the markets you are interested in by accessing exclusive content from