China Coal-To-Olefins Projects Not Just About Oil Prices

Business, China, Company Strategy, Environment, Olefins, Polyolefins

By John Richardson

dirtycoalCHINA will do what suits China from a national perspective. Remember this in all your new thinking about how its chemicals industry will behave in the future and I think you will be on the right tracks.

So, as in the past, you cannot afford to look at the cost-per-tonne economics of producing a particular chemical in isolation and assume that this alone will drive future investment decisions.

I therefore challenge the view put forward by UBS in a recent report where they argue that lower oil prices mean that less coal-based ethylene capacity was likely to go ahead in China. Cheaper crude, on paper at least, erodes the cost advantage that coal-based producers enjoy versus those who make their ethylene via naphtha (naphtha is, of course, made from crude).

The fall in oil prices has led the investment bank to lower its forecast for total ethylene capacity in China in 2019. It now expects 26.93m tonnes/year of C2s capacity to exist in China by the end of that year – 13% lower than its previous prediction.

The bank believes that these project cancellations or postponements will result in a sharp rise in ethylene and derivatives imports between 2014 and 2019. This might, as a result, create sufficient room for many of the US ethylene and polyethylene projects due on-stream over the next few years. It could also make some of the new cracker complexes being planned in Southeast Asia considerably more viable.

But I think it is important for reasonable people to disagree. This is an important debate. Here are some of the other arguments that I think are also worth evaluating:

  • Most of China’s coal-to-olefins (CTO projects are in rural areas where job creation is more important that profitability. Build a CTO plant and you create lots of employment downstream through polymer plants and plastic processing facilities etc.
  • And in the great scheme of things, adding a CTO complex to a huge coal gasification site in China might not be that major an investment decision. So the attitude might be, “OK, we already spending billions of dollars on building plants that use gasified coal to make synthetic natural gas, kerosene, gasoline, diesel, ammonia and methanol. Adding a CTO plant to this investment cost is therefore not such a big  deal, especially if the plant creates a bit of ‘societal value’ by diversifying a local economy.”
  • And let’s say that a lot of these new CTO plants are indeed built. How might they operate in the event of persistently low oil prices? Perhaps at higher rates than some people think because of the job creation factor.

But still, there is the issue of water consumption. Is there enough water to build these complexes the first place? Opinion remains divided on this issue, although I tend to favour the view that where there is a will, China will find a way.

If turning coal to gas and then all its downstream products is a strategic priority, then China will find a way of getting around this problem.  And I believe that building coal gasification complexes might well turn out to be a long-term strategic priority.


China's New "For Profit" Chemicals Industry? Think Again....


By John Richardson IF you think that running a chemicals company in China can be...

Learn more

The Developing World: Getting Your Strategy Right


By John Richardson IT IS just plain intellectually lazy, and, more importantly, ...

Learn more
More posts
Developed world polymers demand: layer after layer of new complexity

By John Richardson THE PROPOSITION that petrochemicals and polymers demand in the developed will see...

China rapid rebound promises another great year for petchems, but beware of the fault lines

By John Richardson IT helped immensely that as the rest of the world was shutting down, China’s fa...

Plastic rubbish: the pandemic is increasing rather than reducing the pressure for change

This is the first of a series of blog posts where I will examine the environmental paradigm shift an...

Retreat of globalisation and implications for petrochemicals

By John Richardson EVER SINCE the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, and the last great geopolitical struggle...

European petrochemicals at risk of delayed demand collapse as new business model emerges

By John Richardson AS DELEGATES take part in this year’s virtual annual European Petrochemical Ass...

US polyethylene: resilient demand could be at risk from delay to new stimulus

By John Richardson THIS REMAINS a mystery that needs to be solved: why US polyethylene (PE) markets ...

China petrochemicals demand boom remains heavily reliant on finished goods exports

By John Richardson THERE will be a lot of official data released about booming consumer spending dur...

Petrochemicals and autos: the last 50 years provide little guide to the future

By John Richardson IT HAS been an amazingly half a century of innovation for the petrochemicals indu...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more