By John Richardson

Coal2OctoberIT has become the accepted wisdom over the last few years that the coal-to-olefins (CTO) process in China consumes a lot of water.

This theory has been expressed in so many conference papers and in research papers that this “truism” is part of just about every discussion on the viability of CTO projects.

But what if the water issue is, in fact, nothing more than a great urban myth, an apocryphal tale that has developed a life of its own?

Duncan Seddon, a Melbourne Australia-based oil, gas and chemicals consultant argues to this effect when he says the following:

  • The gasification of coal uses oxygen, which is produced from large air separation units. Virtually all of this oxygen is converted into water; this water can thus be used as process water with minimal clean-up. There is some requirement for make-up water (boiler quality) but this is not large.
  • In addition, coal generally contains a lot of moisture (especially for sub-bituminous or lignite – Latrobe valley lignite – this is 60% water). There are technologies out there to extract water from this type of coal, which can then, of course, be used in further processes.
  • But there is an issue around cooling when the methanol-to-olefins (MTO) stage is reached, as the MTO process works at 50% thermal efficiency. This means that 50% of the coal used is in effect burned and the heat generated has to be discharged to the environment.
  • An easy, and cheap, way of doing this cooling is to use river water for cooling, and so this is where you can end up with huge consumption of water per tonne of olefins produced.
  • But there is no reason, other than capital costs, to use river water as you can instead use:
  1. A cooling tower, where a circuit of cooling water is used. Up to 15% of water can disappear into the atmosphere out of the top of these cooling towers, but it is also possible to further invest in a closed-loop system, which re-condenses the steam.
  2. Another approach is to air cool plants, which means you would use no water for cooling at all in the MTO step.

And so, if Seddon’s views are accurate, it doesn’t necessarily matter a jot that many of  the CTO projects are in arid areas, where water is in tight supply.

Why? Because, potentially, they can be net producers of water, provided the right capital spending takes place.

Back in July, a source with an oil, gas and chemicals company also suggested that water was not an issue for the CTO process in China. However, his argument was different. He claimed that whilst the process did, indeed, consume a lot of water, the government was determined, for energy security reasons, to get over the problem.

Obviously, though, if Seddon’s views are accurate, tackling the water issue it is just a question, as we said, of money  – and  does not require, as many people think, technological innovation. Cooling towers and air cooling are technologies that have been around for many years.

One could argue, of course, that CTO is still an environmentally harmful process in terms of sulphur, particulate matter and carbon emissions.

But as we also discussed in our July post, there is another important argument here: Because  gasification projects often involve making synthetic natural gas that replaces coal in power generation, the gasification process can help solve China’s air pollution problems. If they are making lots of synthetic natural gas, diesel, gasoline etc. in a big integrated complex, adding methanol-to-olefins adds a bit more economic value – and crucially, also, social value to such a complex.

On the angle of water, the environmentalists might be barking up the wrong tree by claiming that these projects always, by their very nature, consume a lot of water. They should instead, perhaps, be pressurising project proponents to spend money on cooling towers etc.

This could also be another test for the viability of a particular project. If it doesn’t include a cooling tower or air cooling in its configuration, will it get approval if it is located in an arid area?

PREVIOUS POST

China's Polyolefins Supply Surge: The Bigger Picture

01/10/2014

By John Richardson ON paper, the polyolefins supply surge in China during 2014 i...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China: A Deliberate "Snowball Effect"

03/10/2014

By John Richardson EARLIER this week we answered this question – “How ba...

Learn more
More posts
Here is your guide to Asian and Global HDPE markets in Q4 this year and in 2022
25/10/2021

By John Richardson THE COMING COLLAPSE of China, as I’ve discussed is before, is like commercially...

Read
China’s “Common prosperity” uncertainties multiply as we head into the unknown
21/10/2021

By John Richardson DON’T SAY I didn’t warn you. This article in The Wall Street Journal confirms...

Read
China provides major climate hope as latest IEA report underlines that it is all about the developing world
18/10/2021

By John Richardson WHEN I worked for a UK local newspaper as a “cub” or junior reporter in the 1...

Read
China’s less commodity intensive future requires major petchem strategic rethink
14/10/2021

By John Richardson THE THING about the collapse of China is that, like commercially viable nuclear f...

Read
China pulls multiple policy levers to fix energy shortages but don’t forget secular fall in demand
11/10/2021

By John Richardson Executive Summary CHINA’S POWER shortages could fixed by the end of this month ...

Read
China petchem project cancellations on “common prosperity” may not mean higher imports
06/10/2021

By John Richardson IT IS BEING suggested that China’s “common prosperity” policy pivot, the bi...

Read
China traditional Q4 petchems demand increase unlikely because of economic rebalancing
04/10/2021

By John Richardson A NEW RESEARCH PAPER by economists Kenneth Rogoff and Yuanchen Yang underlines th...

Read
China carbon limits and Evergrande tied together as short term growth challenges build
28/09/2021

By John Richardson Executive summary THE LIKELIHOOD that 227,000 tonnes of China’s polyethylene (P...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more