Oil Prices: Ignore Human Nature At Your Peril

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Europe, Oil & Gas, South Korea, US

By John Richardson

HumanbeingspictureJUST four months after the blog first moved to Asia, we got the shock of our lives: The Asian Financial Crisis.

We were bewildered and didn’t know what to think, but fortunately, perhaps, there wasn’t much of an Internet in those days. So we had smaller mountains of news and analysis to distract us.

So instead we picked up the phone and talked to people. Yes, this is still quite useful.

And one of the people we talked to said with great authority, when the crisis spread to South Korea: “Three of the country’s crackers will definitely have to shut down because they simply cannot carry on losing money like this.”

We believed him and published the story. But the crackers kept running as they carried on bleeding money for another 12-18 months. The markets then turned for the better. All three crackers are still on-line today, and two have undergone major expansions.

This taught us two things, which were:

1.) We were idiots to publish the story before talking to people in South Korea. We never made that same mistake again.

2.) Not everything in the world can be understood from cost-per-tonne analysis. Human nature, politics, different business cultures, different cultures and societies in general – they all also matter hugely. This became clear when we talked to people in South Korea, including lots of visits to this great country. Good cost-per-tonne analysis is vital work, but other things count as well.

Wind forward to today. A lot of the talk in oil markets at the moment centres on at what point the higher cost US shale capacity will shut down. It is assumed that once this capacity shuts down, the world will return to the old normal of stable prices in the region of $100 a barrel.

But  here are some thoughts on this, based  on, again, talking to people and wandering up and down our local beach:

  • It depends on what return on investment you think that producers in the US will be satisfied with.
  • What if they end up being happy with much lower rates of return than most people have forecast?
  • What happens if they keep on producing, as oil prices continue to tumble, in order to protect their market shares?
  • And why shut down when you are still earning some money, even if it isn’t much? You will still  have to pay your debt back if you are not running, and, of course, if you are not running, you will have NO revenue.
  • Isn’t it therefore much better to “tough it out” and to wait for a recovery in oil prices?
  • And what if  some shale oil producers go bust? Might their debt be written off and might they then be taken over by private equity players? These new owners would then only have to cover variable costs.

This might end up being  very wrong and, as, a good friend of the blog, Shivprasad Naik, Senior Vice President for polyvinyl chloride with India’s Reliance Industries, warned us yesterday: “Only two people can forecast oil prices. Either one has to be  a fool or a god.  Since none of us are gods, we don’t want to prove to the contrary.”

But our point is that human nature, although it is often devilishly hard to predict, has to always be taken into account.

And so the above scenario, where US shale oil production carries on running harder than some people predict, should be built into your business planning.

Very recent history has taught us that do this kind of thinking. How many of us,  just a few weeks ago, predicted that for geopolitical reasons, Saudi Arabia would chase market share rather than try to prop up prices by cutting back on its production?

The great news in all of this, for people who have to tell their bosses to go left or right, and not hang around in the useless middle, is this:  When it comes to the demand for oil,  we think that human beings are telling us something that is clear as the difference between night and day.

Human nature, which helped us interpret the data, has led us to these conclusions:

  • The ability to gamble either in oil, other commodities, equities and high-end Chinese properties used to be huge, thanks to central bank stimulus.
  • This meant that real supply and demand for crude didn’t matter much at all. Markets lost their role of price discovery.
  • Now that central bank stimulus is being withdrawn,  real price discovery has returned  to oil markets.
  • Crude had never really been affordable at $100 a barrel, but financial markets didn’t care about the damage they were causing to real demand during the era of “false calm” created by all that easy central bank money.

As we said the other day, ‘be careful what your wish for”The world simply cannot afford $100 a barrel crude and so if prices recovered to this level, they would soon retreat again.

What the world instead needs is stable, lower oil prices. This would be great news for major oil importing countries, such as India and China.  And it would help the world economy in general to adjust to the New Normal.

Here’s a final thought: If production cutbacks fail to keep prices anywhere near $100 a barrel  on a long-term basis, chasing market share might end up being the priority of most producers, not just the lowest cost producers in the world – the Saudis. 

PREVIOUS POST

China's September "Export Boom". Are You Serious?

15/10/2014

By John Richardson WHEN something seems to be so obviously too good to be true, ...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China: How To Chart The Future

20/10/2014

By John Richardson THE chart below should not be printed out and pinned on any c...

Learn more
More posts
China moves closer to Iran as tensions with the US build: Implications for petrochemicals
02/08/2020

By John Richardson Opinions and emotions and can shape how we interpret data, but, as we all know, o...

Read
China polyolefins market H1 review: so far so good, but beware of the risks ahead
30/07/2020

By John Richardson ALL looks fine in the polyolefins world. The Old Normal appears to have reasserte...

Read
Polyethylene market recovery could be threatened by slower China crude buying, weaker economic growth
28/07/2020

By John Richardson EVEN by China’s standards, where just about every number is eye-wateringly larg...

Read
Why the polypropylene industry must switch from volumes to value
26/07/2020

By John Richardson EVERYONE knows about the oversupply in the polyethylene (PE) market as it has bee...

Read
China consulate closure underlines long-term split with US, potential big shift in petchems trade flows
23/07/2020

The views in this blog post are, as always, my personal views and do not reflect the views of ICIS. ...

Read
China’s real GDP could have been negative in Q2: What this may mean for PP
22/07/2020

By John Richardson CHINA’S official GDP growth of 3.2% for Q2, which was announced last week, may ...

Read
Iran and China new deal could hasten Belt & Road Initiative petrochemicals self-sufficiency
19/07/2020

By John Richardson ONCE AGAIN, please don’t say I didn’t tell you. A proposed new investment and...

Read
China paraxylene imports head for bigger declines as excess industrial production appears to boost GDP
17/07/2020

By John Richardson SOME PEOPLE see the 9.9% year-on-year rise in China’s crude oil imports in Janu...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more