Buoyant, Calm Financial Markets Fail to Reflect Growing Risks

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Environment, Oil & Gas, US


By John Richardson

THE Chicago Board Options Exchange’s (CBOE) volatility index fell to its lowest level since 1993 on 8 May.

But we knew then that the China economy was slowing down – and that very probably, the Trump administration would fail in its efforts to achieve meaningful tax cuts and infrastructure spending.

Financial markets have since then become even more becalmed – and have also reached new record highs – despite another North Korean missile test and, in the space of just one week, President Trump’s dismissal of former FBI chief James Comey and the controversy over claims that the president leaked sensitive intelligence information during a meeting with Russian government officials. These distractions suggest it will be even harder for President Trump to achieve his growth-boosting policy agenda (that’s if you accept the view that his proposed measures, which right now are short on detail, would actually boost growth).

Since 8 May, China’s April trade, industrial production and retail sales data have also further confirmed that China’s 2017 economic growth almost certainly peaked in Q1 at 6.9%. This stronger first quarter performance gives the Chinese government plenty of leeway to allow the economy to cool down over the next few quarters whilst still hitting their annual growth target for 2017 of 6.5%. It also has the leeway, and plenty of popular support, to improve air quality in the big cities. This year’s environmental clean-up campaign is tied-in with lower lending growth – and will add to downward pressure on GDP growth.

What is even more remarkable about the lack of volatility in financial markets is the role that stronger Chinese growth has played in stronger global growth. As a reminder:

  • The global economic recovery has had very little to do with a fundamental shift in the underlying growth dynamics in key developed economies such as the US. Until or unless the US and the rest of the West tackles the challenges of ageing populations, a sustainable recovery cannot happen.
  • What has instead been behind the recovery has been a mini commodities pricing bubble. In 2016, commodities prices rose as the Chinese economy boomed on a rapid growth in lending. This was the result of the Populist anti-reform political faction regaining control of China’s economy. Global deflation thus turned to reflation as global manufacturers hedged against higher raw material costs by building up their inventories of raw materials.
  • But this year’s slowdown in lending demonstrates that the Princeling pre-form political faction led  by Xi Jinping, China’s president, is back in control of the economy. Prices of commodities such as iron ore have, as a result, started to decline as credit conditions in China tighten.

So markets should now be pricing-in the strong possibility that the recent strength in purchasing manager’s indices (PMIs) in Europe and the US will start dissipating. What could soon become apparent is that the stronger demand being reported by companies in the West has largely been just the restocking effect described above. PMIs could thus soon weaken, especially if the China slowdown helps drive oil prices lower.

Why are finanical markets becalmed markets then? Mohamed El-Erian, former head of Pimco, the world’s biggest bond fund manager, told the British newspaper, The Guardian:

Investors have been conditioned to think central banks can suppress volatility. They also see that the low growth appears stable.

But the above chart is an important reminder how the central bank that matters more than all the other central banks – the People’s Bank of China – is now in lending contraction mode. Sure, it may change course, but this seems unlikely over the next few quarters and into early 2018. Please be careful out there.


China's Drive To PX Self-Sufficiency Again Shows Failure Of Conventional Thinking


By John Richardson BACK in November 2014, when I first suggested that China migh...

Learn more

China Moves Towards Commodity Grade PE Self-Sufficiency By 2025


By John Richardson THE argument I’ve been making for a couple of years now is ...

Learn more
More posts
BASF’s shocking Q2 results should have been no shock at all

y John Richardson NOBODY should be surprised by the BASF results for Q1 2019 where, on a year-on-yea...

Multiple trade disputes and the risks for the US PE industry

By John Richardson FALLING out with a trading partner as big as China is problematic enough. But the...

China PE overstocking at nearly a million tonnes as demand weakens, competition intensifies

By John Richardson MEASURING petrochemicals and polymer inventory levels in China with any reasonabl...

China petrochemicals recovery on G20 trade war progress will be shortlived

By John Richardson China petrochemical and polymer price spreads over naphtha feedstock costs will r...

President Trump’s Vietnam warning threatens more polyethylene disruptions

Just to stress  that, as always, what follows are my own personal views and not those of ICIS By Jo...

US LLDPE imports and the impact on European petrochemicals

  By John Richardson EUROPEAN linear-low density polyethylene (LLDPE) markets have yet to feel ...

Southeast Asia PE spreads further underline weak demand, but trade talks promise rebound

By John Richardson THE GOOD news today is that the US and China have agreed to resume trade talks. P...

Global polyethylene: Supply is not the problem, it is demand

By John Richardson WHEN people talk about supply it is very often because it is much easier to quant...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more