US Stock Market Decline Highlights Consumer Spending, Income And Debt Risks

Business, Company Strategy, Economics, US

By John Richardson

THE SUSTAINABILITY of the US economic recovery rests on the willingness of people who cannot afford to spend money to continue to spend money.

In order to explain what I mean, let’s start with income and wealth distribution in the US.

A US Federal Reserve study showed that the 90% of US families at the bottom the economic pile made less than half of the country’s wealth in 2016. This was down from 62% in 1992.

In terms of wealth, the bottom 90% held just 22.8% of total US wealth in 2016, down from around one third in 1992. Meanwhile, the top 1% controlled a record-high 38.6% of US wealth in 2016, said the same study.

Another study is also cause for concern. The median 40% of adult earners controlled 28% of total US wealth in 2014, according to World Health and Income Database. This was down from 37% in 1986.

Sure, Labor Department data released last week showed that January hourly earnings rose by 0.3%, which was enough to lift the annual rate of increase to 2.9%.

But wage growth for “production non-supervisory” positions – the bottom 83% of the jobs market – was only 2.4% higher on an annual basis.

This suggests that the percentage increase for the top 17% of the US workforce was a lot higher than the overall average of 2.9%. In other words, there has been a further increase in inequality.

Also, take a look at the two Deutsche Bank charts at the beginning of this blog post from a total of eight charts provided by the bank.

As you can see from the chart on the left, more US families than ever before had zero non-home wealth in 2016. The chart on the right shows how young people appear to be slipping behind in terms of their net worth.

And yet in November 2017, US credit card debt reached $1.023 trillion. This was higher than in April 2008 – just  before the Global Financial Crisis.

Why? It is a confidence thing. People are prepared to build up debt today if they believe economic conditions will be better in the future, even if their personal outgoings don’t immediately justify the spending. As Michael Schreiber quite brilliantly wrote in this NBC News article:

Let’s imagine a middle class family with good credit. Their salaries aren’t going up, certainly not enough to keep up with their skyrocketing healthcare costs.

They live in the northeast and they’ve just found out that their insanely high property taxes are no longer deductible; they’re tired of all cold weather, and they could really use a vacation. They can’t really afford to take one, but they did get a credit card offer in the mail with a zero percent APR introductory offer.

It’s like a $100 bill burning a hole in their pockets. They decide, a bit on a whim, to get the credit card and find a deal for an all-inclusive vacation to Jamaica, where they’ve always wanted to go.

“But what about the stock markets?” I hear you say. That’s right. Paper wealth for many people has gone up thanks to the record-breaking equity market bull run.

But the Fed study I quoted earlier on found that only around one third of the economic bottom 50% owned shares in 2016 either directly or indirectly. Of the one third, the average stock portfolio was worth just $52,000 – lower than in 2013.

Consumer confidence at risk

As we all know, the Dow Jones Industrial Average last week saw its worst week since early 2016. On Friday alone the market was down by 666 points – -2.5%.

This was the result of concerns that inflation would force interest rates higher than had been anticipated. Bond yields responded accordingly, with the ten-year Treasury yield set to test 3% for the first time in four years.

Another factor behind the sell-off was said to be political turbulence in Washington. Nothing new here, of course, but when the mood becomes gloomy, all negatives that have been out of focus tend to come into focus.

A declining stock market could dent consumer confidence as even amongst people who don’t own equities, the value of stocks are seen as an indication of the strength of the economy. Consumer confidence recently reached a 17-year high.

US consumer confidence indices are thus worth watching as they are a good leading indicator of a recession, according to Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller.

Consumer spending would also quite obviously suffer if interest rates continue to rise

Might substantial tranches of consumer debt have to once again be written off? Seeking Alpha wrote on 23 January:

In the current environment, a 25 bps hike in Fed rate, if fully passed through to household credit markets, will increase the cost of household credit by USD 32.4 billion per annum. The same shock five years ago would have cost the U.S. household USD 28.3 billion per annum.

Fundamental weaknesses

By the time you read this article, the market could have bounced back and may go on to new highs.

But this would do little to resolve the US income and wealth gap. These are symptoms of the impact of automation on global labour markets and the effect of an ageing population on underlying, long- term consumption patterns.

Because these challenges are not being met another US recession is inevitable, with the only question being its timing.

My views are a long way from the consensus and I of course could be wrong – very wrong.  Let’s have a data-driven debate on this issue.

Meanwhile, be warned that the consensus isn’t always right. Chemicals and other companies would be wise to plan for a significant slowdown in the US economy.


China Accelerates Pollution Campaign In 2018: Implications For Chemicals


By John Richardson ON THE surface of things there will be no let up when China...

Learn more

House Of Cards Waiting To Fall: Oil, Equities And The Economy


By John Richardson HOW much of the rise in oil prices since June of last year ha...

Learn more
More posts
China’s “Common prosperity” uncertainties multiply as we head into the unknown

By John Richardson DON’T SAY I didn’t warn you. This article in The Wall Street Journal confirms...

China provides major climate hope as latest IEA report underlines that it is all about the developing world

By John Richardson WHEN I worked for a UK local newspaper as a “cub” or junior reporter in the 1...

China’s less commodity intensive future requires major petchem strategic rethink

By John Richardson THE THING about the collapse of China is that, like commercially viable nuclear f...

China pulls multiple policy levers to fix energy shortages but don’t forget secular fall in demand

By John Richardson Executive Summary CHINA’S POWER shortages could fixed by the end of this month ...

China petchem project cancellations on “common prosperity” may not mean higher imports

By John Richardson IT IS BEING suggested that China’s “common prosperity” policy pivot, the bi...

China traditional Q4 petchems demand increase unlikely because of economic rebalancing

By John Richardson A NEW RESEARCH PAPER by economists Kenneth Rogoff and Yuanchen Yang underlines th...

China carbon limits and Evergrande tied together as short term growth challenges build

By John Richardson Executive summary THE LIKELIHOOD that 227,000 tonnes of China’s polyethylene (P...

Challenges facing China as it tries to bridge the rural-urban wealth divide

By John Richardson THIS COULD be the biggest event in our industry since at least the Global Financi...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more