Stand Back And Think: Can This Oil-Price Rally Really Last?

Australia, Business, China, Company Strategy, Oil & Gas, Olefins, Polyolefins, US

By John Richardson

US-crude-oil-stocks-2015-02-11THE talk in oil markets right now is largely about falling US rig counts and how this has resulted in tighter supply.

But it is very important to note that this focus on the rig count is a recent phenomenon.

“People have only started paying attention to the oil rig count in the past week despite the fact they have been falling for weeks,” Gene McGillian, analyst at Tradition Energy in Stamford, Connecticut, told Reuters in this 6 February article.

“I think the people really benefiting from these market gyrations are the high frequency traders (HFT) as volumes are really up,” McGillan added.

Bullish news stories on oil have thus soared in number since late January, which has been picked up by the algorithms operated by the HTF traders. This “evidence” of a more positive outlook has prompted the HTF traders to increase their long positions in oil markets.

As the HTF traders have gone longer, and as other people have jumped on the bandwagon, oil has gone even higher, resulting in an a greater volume of stories about how crude has finally bottomed out. These stories have again been picked by the algorithms run by the HTF traders and the cycle has repeated itself.

This is fine if you are an oil trader who has already made the right bets.

But it is not so fine for either petrochemicals producers or buyers if this recovery in oil loses its momentum. Anybody who buys, say, naphtha or polyethylene resin ahead of further rises in crude that do not materialise  might well end up in a lot of trouble.

It essential, therefore, to stand back, look closely at this rig count story, and ask yourself this question: “Can this oil-price recovery really last?”

Here are some facts to consider:

  • While US companies have idled 151 rigs in five shale formations since reaching a peak of 1,157 in October, they’ll need to shut down another 200 for oil-production growth to stall, according to the US Energy Information Administration (EIA).
  • US shale-based output is still expected by the EIA to reach an all-time record high of 5.47m million barrels a day in March.
  • The US shale industry has become better at blasting crude out of deep underground layers of rock, according to productivity data tracked by the EIA in the major shale prospects including the Bakken, Eagle Ford, Niobrara, Permian and Utica. These improvements have helped overcome the natural depletion of existing wells.
  • As drillers cut costs, the less efficient equipment is idled first while the best machinery is dispatched to the most promising acreage, which boosts the amount of crude produced for every rig in the field.
  • US crude in storage remains at an 80-year high and there have been reports that foreign producers have been leasing tankers to sail around in circles with cargoes of crude waiting for the price to rise. No one, apparently, wants to be the first to cut production, preferring instead to take a “wait-and-see” approach.
  • With storage US storage tanks full to the brim, from March onwards the turnaround season at US refineries is set to begin. This will weaken demand.
  • The price when producers chicken out isn’t necessarily the average cost of production, which for 80% of new US shale oil production this year will be $50 to $69 a barrel, according to Daniel Yergin of energy consultant IHS Cambridge Energy Research Associates.
  •  Instead, the chicken-out point, as I have been arguing since last October, is the marginal cost of production, or the additional costs after the wells are drilled and the pipes are laid. This “chicken out” point is when cash flow falls to zero.
  • Last month, Wood Mackenzie, the energy consultancy, found that of 2,222 oil fields surveyed worldwide, only 1.6% would have negative cash flow at $40 a barrel. The marginal cost for efficient US shale-oil producers is about $10 to $20 a barrel in the Permian Basin in Texas and about the same for oil produced in the Persian Gulf.
  • For arguments sake, and this is a real stretch, let’s pretend that all of this is wrong and US production cuts are already very deep.  Oil prices might then continue to rise, shale production would surely increase again. The difficulty then is that the Saudi Arabians could then pump even more oil as they play their “long game” of winning back market share, leading to another retreat in the oil price.

The other key element here, worth separate mention, is obviously demand. China is slowing, along with the rest of the global economy. The Paris–based International Energy Agency recently reduced its 2015 global demand forecast for the fourth time in 12 months by 230,000 barrels a day to 93.3 million and sees supply exceeding demand this year by 400,000 barrels a day.

PREVIOUS POST

China After The Lunar New Year: Your Five-Point Guide

16/02/2015

By John Richardson HERE is a five-point guide to what will happen in China after...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China By Itself Is Not A Strategy

18/02/2015

By John Richardson SOMETIMES a bit of data is worth many thousands of words – ...

Learn more
More posts
Here is your guide to Asian and Global HDPE markets in Q4 this year and in 2022
25/10/2021

By John Richardson THE COMING COLLAPSE of China, as I’ve discussed is before, is like commercially...

Read
China’s “Common prosperity” uncertainties multiply as we head into the unknown
21/10/2021

By John Richardson DON’T SAY I didn’t warn you. This article in The Wall Street Journal confirms...

Read
China provides major climate hope as latest IEA report underlines that it is all about the developing world
18/10/2021

By John Richardson WHEN I worked for a UK local newspaper as a “cub” or junior reporter in the 1...

Read
China’s less commodity intensive future requires major petchem strategic rethink
14/10/2021

By John Richardson THE THING about the collapse of China is that, like commercially viable nuclear f...

Read
China pulls multiple policy levers to fix energy shortages but don’t forget secular fall in demand
11/10/2021

By John Richardson Executive Summary CHINA’S POWER shortages could fixed by the end of this month ...

Read
China petchem project cancellations on “common prosperity” may not mean higher imports
06/10/2021

By John Richardson IT IS BEING suggested that China’s “common prosperity” policy pivot, the bi...

Read
China traditional Q4 petchems demand increase unlikely because of economic rebalancing
04/10/2021

By John Richardson A NEW RESEARCH PAPER by economists Kenneth Rogoff and Yuanchen Yang underlines th...

Read
China carbon limits and Evergrande tied together as short term growth challenges build
28/09/2021

By John Richardson Executive summary THE LIKELIHOOD that 227,000 tonnes of China’s polyethylene (P...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more