Measuring Crude Prices And Asian Petchems Profitability

Business, China, Economics, Middle East, Naphtha & other feedstocks, Oil & Gas, Olefins, Polyolefins

By John Richardson

YESTERDAY I posted this slide on LinkedIn, in response to a lot of concern amongst the more than 150 or so delegates at the 5th ICIS Asian Polyolefins Conference in Bangkok about the impact of rising crude prices on profitability.

The chart shows spreads between naphtha costs, CFR China injection grade HDPE prices and the prices for selected co-products (see below for the full details about the methodology behind the slide). The orange bars represent the spreads with the blue line Brent crude prices. Oil prices obviously drive the cost of naphtha.

The slide shows the great value of ICIS pricing data and the data crunching done by our ICIS Consulting and Analytics teams.

Now let me explain in detail the significance of what this slide is telling is about the past, and the risks for the future.

The 2014-2017 margins boom

The first big oil price shock of the 2000s occurred between 2005 and 2008. In 2008, as oil prices climbed to an average of $97/bbl from $72/bbl the previous year, spreads fell to $427/tonne from $720/tonne.

Then came, of, course, the Global Financial Crisis, the collapse of crude and its subsequent rally in 2009-2013.  Spreads actually held up OK as they averaged $738/tonne during those years.

The last few years have seen record high spreads. Spreads averaged $1,219/tonne between 2014 and October of this year.

Spreads are of course not margins, but point towards margins, which ICIS also assesses. See the slide below for our assessment of historic Northeast Asian HDPE integrated variable cost margins. This includes all the co-products, minus feedstock and production costs.

This helps to underline my point on Monday that much higher crude on increased geopolitical tensions is a major risk for Asian cracker earnings next year.

Let’s assume that the worst doesn’t happen. There isn’t a new war between Israel and Lebanon and there is no major clash between the Iraqi government and the Iraqi Kurds. This still doesn’t necessarily mean that the crude rally which began in July will not continue into 2018.

One reason is that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman must deliver to Saudi Arabia’s very youthful population now that he, and his branch of the royal family, have greatly increased their control over the government. The surest way of doing this is to push oil prices higher that would generate the funds to pay for more job creation and social programmes.

Secondly, higher oil prices would also raise the revenues from the Aramco IPO that is due to take place next year.

Background behind the slide

It takes approximately 3.3 tonnes of naphtha to make one tonne of ethylene, the core product for any steam cracker and then very close to one tonne of ethylene to make a tonne of HDPE.

So it’s simple to multiply the prevailing naphtha prices in 2000-2017 by 3.3 tonnes. You can then compare the spreads between these total costs of naphtha to make a tonne of ethylene/HDPE with China CFR China HDPE prices.

This points towards how profitable the Asian PE industry has been since 2000 on a standalone basis (As discussed last week, in every year since 2000 on a standalone basis, money has been lost).

But this isn’t how the industry operates, as more than 90% of Asian PE capacity is integrated through to naphtha and other liquid or gas feedstocks – i.e. the PE producers own and operate their own crackers.

So you need to add the co-product credits that you also make when you crack 3.3 tonnes of naphtha to make a tonne of ethylene. You also get, roughly speaking again, 0.52 tonnes of propylene, 0.33 tonnes of C4 olefins, 0.75 tonnes aromatics plus fuel-type products.

I have thus added multiples of the prevailing propylene prices, butadiene prices (ICIS pricing doesn’t track the pricing over C4 olefins) and an average of benzene, toluene and mixed xylene prices.

I didn’t add any values from fuel-oil type products, or any extra money a naphtha cracker operator might make from selling ethylene into the highly volatile, but often very lucrative, Asian spot ethylene market.

PREVIOUS POST

Global Economy Is Less Able To Withstand A New Oil Price Shock

12/11/2017

By John Richardson YESTERDAY I posted this slide on LinkedIn, in response to a l...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China Govt Policy To Shape Petchems Demand, Pricing In 2018

17/11/2017

By John Richardson YESTERDAY I posted this slide on LinkedIn, in response to a l...

Learn more
More posts
China’s paraxylene imports in 2019-2025 face major downside risks
21/05/2019

By John Richardson NEVER underestimate China’s ability to execute vast and highly complex manufact...

Read
China benzene spreads at ten-year low on misplaced trade deal hopes
19/05/2019

By John Richardson THE ABOVE chart shows that in April the average spread between CFR Japan naphtha ...

Read
Longer trade war: Impact in numbers on China polymers demand
15/05/2019

By John Richardson WE MUST now start to quantify the impact on the petrochemicals industry of no end...

Read
Plastics pollution crisis: Impact on polyethylene margins in 2022-2027
13/05/2019

By John Richardson ALMOST all countries late last week signed a UN deal to monitor the flow of hard-...

Read
China PE demand boom will not stop further margin declines
10/05/2019

By John Richardson CHINA’S polyethylene (PE) market is being temporarily weighed down by overstock...

Read
China holds all the petchems demand aces as it digs in for longer trade war
08/05/2019

By John Richardson THE STRENGTH of China’s position in the intensifying trade war is further under...

Read
President Trump’s Tweets increase risk of no trade deal until 2021
06/05/2019

By John Richardson THE PROSPECTS of a trade deal seem to have have faded into the distance as a resu...

Read
Pressure on US builds as PE exports to China tumble and EU considers tariffs
03/05/2019

By John Richardson DONALD TRUMP insisted in early March that he was willing to walk away from a bad ...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more