China and India: When Over-Investment Is A Good Thing

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Environment, India, Innnovation, Sustainability, Technology


By John Richardson

WHEN is over-investment a good thing? This was another question the blog was left pondering after a good conversation with a Beijing-based training delegate during ICIS Training’s recent China Seminar in Bangkok.

She made the point that China builds roads, bridges and railways, which ends up “seeding” or developing demand in less-developed provinces. So what if this incurs temporary debt problems? In the long term, the benefits are great. For example, a farmer might be able to operate a market stall in a nearby town three days a week, rather than just one, because his travel time has been cut in half.

Similarly, if you build a petrochemicals plant in a remote province that seems way too big for the local market, the idea is that this will form the basis for much wider downstream industrial development (there is a parallel here in what might also be happening in Southeast Asia). For example, China’s largest cracker at 1.22m tonnes/year is at Dushanzi in the western province if Xianjiang, where per capita GDP was only Rmb33,909 in 2012 compared with Rmb85,033 in Shanghai province.

This is not to say that China doesn’t have a serious over-investment problem. It must be much more careful in the way it spends money to prevent a systemic debt crisis, whilst also tackling an environmental crisis caused by too much of the wrong type of industrial capacity.

But, amidst all the distorted incentives at a local level, China’s central government has long had a plan – and now has a huge opportunity to make its new economic plan work for the benefit of the whole country, rather than just a small number of people at the top of society.

Not so, perhaps India. As this Financial Times article by Ruchir Sharma of JP Morgan argues “the inflation problem says a lot about what has gone wrong with India’s economic model under the Congress party.

“The government has let fuel and fertiliser subsidies spin out of control and has bought wheat and rice at artificially high prices to appease large farmers. It has been building an expansive welfare state, rather than pursuing reforms to boost productivity. The government has also been pushing up wages through, for example, measures to guarantee employment to rural workers. Over the past five years rural wages have been rising at an annual pace of 15% – faster than productivity growth and higher than in any other Asian country.

“Now India appears to be catching the Latin American disease: rising prices and falling growth.”

But it would be grossly unfair just to blame all the problems on the current government. Years of under-investment in roads and ports etc have meant that demand hasn’t been sufficiently seeded. Instead it flounders, as the above chart illustrates, because of not enough jobs and an economy too dependent on agriculture.

How can India progress from here? This is a subject we shall return to in detail over the coming weeks and months as we talk to people in the Indian chemicals industry.


The WTO "Bali" Deal Versus ASEAN Priorities


By John Richardson WHY sacrifice national or regional growth for the sake of fre...

Learn more

The US Growth Conundrum


By John Richardson WHERE is the growth in the US economy going to come from to c...

Learn more
More posts
Coronavirus, impact on the developing world and the scale of demand losses

By John Richardson ALL OF us are struggling to come to terms with a collapse in the global economy t...

Coronavirus, reshoring and the polyester industry: Good luck with that

By John Richardson POLITICIANS, not just including the Populist variety, are talking a lot about res...

Beware of the fragile nature of the oil and petrochemical price recovery

By John Richardson RECENT rises in oil and petrochemicals prices should not in my view be taken as a...

China petrochemical inventories build on what could be false hopes of a V-shaped rebound

By John Richardson AS PETROCHEMICALS storage space in China fills up on the hope that the country ca...

Further polyethylene rate cuts seem inevitable with no certainty on who will blink first

By John Richardson IT IS NOT just a razor-like focus on petrochemicals demand that will get you thro...

What petrochemical companies must do to adapt to a smaller coronavirus economy

By John Richardson PETROCHEMICAL companies can adapt to the coronavirus New Normal by running their ...

Coronavirus and the way forward: Forecasting micro surges in petrochemicals demand

By John Richardson THE MONTH of May is normally a low season for toluene di-isocyanate (TDI) demand ...

Southeast Asia polyolefins demand may fall by as much as during Asian Financial Crisis

By John Richardson HOW do you replace anywhere between 9% and 18% of GDP when it has virtually disap...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more