Mark Twain, the famous US writer, put it well when he warned that:
“It isn’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you think you know for sure.”
This has certainly been the case with auto sales in China. In 2010, leading analysts JD Power expected that “the pace of growth may slow in 2011 after the nation withdrew tax breaks and rural subsidies“. But they still forecast growth of “about 10% a year during the next 4 years.”
2 years later, the chart above highlights the level of over-optimism:
• 2011 sales (green line) saw zero growth versus 2010
• 2012 sales to September (red square) are up just 6%
• Even this growth is probably an over-estimate, as China counts sales at the point when cars leave the factory
• Normalised inventory levels would suggest sales could actually be down 6%
Of course, some still believe that everything will suddenly return to ‘normal’ when the new leadership is finally appointed. But China remains a very poor country, with 96% of the population earning less than $7600/year.
Thus the blog believes future growth will be focused on people trading up from motorbikes to Nissan’s $3k Datsun model. Until such cars are available, it continues to expect sustained growth to be hard to achieve.