Risks for US petrochemicals once again rise as trade war takes another twist

China, Company Strategy, Economics, Fibre Intermediates, Naphtha & other feedstocks, Oil & Gas, Olefins, Polyolefins, US

By John Richardson

JUST when nearly of all us (including me) thought that a trade deal was about to happen, US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer has thrown quite a large spanner in the works.

“I can’t predict success at this point, but we’re working hard and we have made real progress,” he told a Senate Finance Committee earlier this week.

Even if a deal does happen, Lighthizer declined to say whether or not existing trade war tariffs will be removed, according to Bloomberg.

The tariffs could stay in place as a means of ensuring that China sticks to the terms of any deal, seems to be the implication of what he said.

The US may also insist on the right to increase tariffs if it decided that China was in breach of a deal, Bloomberg also reported.

Here is a cause for further concern: The US wants the right to impose new tariffs if it unilaterally decides China is not in compliance, but wants China to guarantee that it wouldn’t reciprocate, according to the Wall Street Journal.

This doesn’t seem like grounds for a solid deal or even a deal at all.

President Trump is also quoted in the same WSJ article as saying he is in no rush to conclude talks and is willing to walk away from a deal.

Bad news for US petchems

I had thought, until a few days ago, that China would agree to buy larger volumes of US energy and agricultural products as part of a deal with the US.

The energy purchases would have mainly involved oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG) as these are a far bigger revenue deal than petrochemicals. But why not throw a few million tonnes of polyethylene (PE) and ethylene glycols into the package?

This would give US petrochemical companies preferential access to a market they must sell more to if they are to make their new investments work.

Perhaps now, though, even if a deal does happen, US petrochemicals will be left out in the cold. If the US insists on maintaining existing trade war tariffs on China why shouldn’t China maintain its tariffs on the US?

Chinese tariffs include the 25% duties imposed from last August on all US grades of high-density PE, all glycols (mono, tri and di-ethylene glycols)  and 93% of the grades of linear-low density.

The above chart is a reminder of what is at stake for the US in 2019-2025, assuming the tariffs meant that it was unable to export very little LLDPE to China.

And the chart below tells us the impact on the US glycols industry if exports to China more or less stopped. (most of this comprises mono-ethylene glycol to supply China’s vast polyester textile and garments value chain).

The charts are based on our estimates of US net exports and the regions and countries that will be net importers.

The charts do not include the imports of countries and regions that are net overall exporters. But they do point to the lopsided China-centric world in which we live, and why, minus China, no heavily export-based world-scale petrochemicals complex can possibly hope to prosper.

If the US were unable to ship to China then smaller net import markets such as Europe, India and South Asia and Southeast Asia would be flooded.

This seems the most likely outcome as US plants would still run hard. Upstream natural gas producers would still need to get rid of unwanted ethane. As with LNG, supplying natural gas to local customers is a much bigger revenue game than petrochemicals.

This would lead to a petrochemicals price war and European and SEA producers might end up successfully petitioning for their own trade barriers.

Or US producers may simply bite the bullet and pay the 25% tariffs. This would still be OK on a variable cost basis, but returns on investments in the new cracker complexes would disappoint investors.

A trade deal could still be done and the tariffs on US petrochemicals removed. But the last few days have at the very least further underlined one new certainty: Success or failure in this business is more heavily driven by geopolitics than feedstock advantage.


China polyethylene demand forecasting: Forget GDP, look downstream and focus on regions


By John Richardson THE TOP DOWN method of estimating polyethylene (PE) demand gr...

Learn more

Per capita consumption another blunt tool for predicting China polymers growth


By John Richardson WE ALREADY know that forecasting Chinese polyethylene (PE) de...

Learn more
More posts
China’s bans on single-use plastics: The impact on polyethylene demand

    By John Richardson DON’T SAY I didn’t tell you. It has always been just a question...

Why the trade deal is much ado about almost nothing

These are, as always, my personal views and do not express the views of ICIS. Thanks By John Richard...

The polymers industry, climate change and a call to action

By John Richardson MUCH OF the debate about plastics and the environment is, I fear, missing the big...

Why President Trump, unlike with Iran, will find it harder to shift course on China

As always, these are my personal views only and do not represent the views of ICIS. Thank you  ...

US and Iran conflict in a world of declining growth and fragile supply chains

By John Richardson THINK of the Fukushima disaster in 2011 and multiply its impact on global supply ...

Iran and the US: Assessing the risks for petrochemicals and the global economy

As always, these are my personal views only and don’t reflect the views of ICIS By John Richar...

China benzene and its derivatives could see negative growth in 2019

        By John Richardson NOW let’s put this all together. My LinkedIn post o...

US/China trade deal achieves little as China pushes hard towards petrochemicals self-sufficiency

By John Richardson PRESIDENT Trump has promised a “tremendous amount of business” for US farmers...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more