Multiple trade disputes and the risks for the US PE industry

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Malaysia, Olefins, Philippines

By John Richardson

FALLING out with a trading partner as big as China is problematic enough. But the US is also out of sorts with the EU, India and Turkey and is at risk of ending up in a dispute with Vietnam.

The row with China is far from being resolved despite the G20 truce. Ninety percent of a trade deal might have been completed, but the really hard bit will be the final 10% as the US and China remain a long way apart on the issues of intellectual property rights protection and Chinese state subsidies for manufacturing. Compromises may well be impossible because President’s Trump and Xi have to keep their domestic supporters happy.

Then there is the dispute with the EU over airline subsidies, a trade war with India following the US decision to withdraw trading privileges and various geopolitical disputes with Turkey, the latest of which relates to the Turkish decision to buy Russian defence equipment.

Vietnam was singled out by President Trump last week as “almost as bad” as China on trade because of a surge in Vietnamese exports to the US. Since then it has emerged that much of this increase involved transhipments – Chinese exports shipped to Vietnam for minimal reprocessing before being moved to the US. In so doing, China avoided US trade-war tariffs.

Illegal transhipment of Chinese goods had also taken place through Malaysia and the Philippines, said a US Customs Department spokesman quoted by the Wall Street Journal. The customs department continues to investigate.

The transhipment trade is said to be worth several billion dollars and seems to have bypassed most of the US tariffs on Chinese imports. This brings into question President Trump’s assertion that the Chinese economy is “going down the tubes” because of the trade war.

Politics, politics and politics. Over the last three years these have become the three most important things you need to consider where assessing petrochemicals and polymers trade flows.

If you don’t believe me, take a look at the above charts. They compare the eight months from January to August 2018, before China imposed its 25% tariffs on US HDPE and LLDPE cargoes, with the eight months afterwards – September 2018 to April 2019.

The US was able to compensate for a fall in exports to China through big gains in other markets, most notably in Belgium (a distribution hub for Europe as a whole), Vietnam, Turkey India and Malaysia.

But what if US disputes with these other regions and countries escalate into tit-for-tat tariffs, including on US PE? In the case of Turkey, it could be more that its economy further contracts as a result of US sanctions. What then for US PE export trade and the economics of its big investments in new capacity? In this context, here are some alarming numbers:

  • Belgium, Malaysia, Turkey and Vietnam – the four countries where the US made its biggest HDPE export gains in September 2018-April 2019 – accounted for 17% of total US exports during that period.
  • LLDPE exports to Malaysia, Vietnam, India, Belgium and Turkey made up 34% of total exports during the same period.
  • US HDPE exports as a percentage of production look set to reach 37% this year, the highest since at least 2000. LLDPE exports as a percentage of production are also likely be at 58%. This would again be a 19-year high.

Perhaps, though, the differences between the US and China are not as intractable as I’ve described above. Maybe the US disputes with everyone else will be resolved whilst the US also backs away from any further confrontations.

But if even this were to happen, the disagreements point to a long term shift in politics. In the US, Britain, Hungary, Poland and elsewhere politicians are questioning the value of globalisation. We are as a result heading towards a much more fragmented world. So much for Francis Fukuyama’s End of History and the triumph of Western liberal democracies as “the final form of human government”.

PREVIOUS POST

China PE overstocking at nearly a million tonnes as demand weakens, competition intensifies

02/07/2019

By John Richardson MEASURING petrochemicals and polymer inventory levels in Chin...

Learn more
NEXT POST

BASF's shocking Q2 results should have been no shock at all

09/07/2019

y John Richardson NOBODY should be surprised by the BASF results for Q1 2019 whe...

Learn more
More posts
Shift in supply chains away from China adds costs, complexities and risks for petrochemicals
11/11/2019

By John Richardson AS PETROCHEMICALS and other manufacturers scramble to relocate their businesses a...

Read
IMF confirms global economy all about China as US threat to growth persists
08/11/2019

By John Richardson DON’T SAY I didn’t tell you. An important new IMF study confirms what I’ve ...

Read
India must forget trying to follow China and should instead launch a Green New Deal
03/11/2019

By John Richardson DON’T WORRY, I am told, India is on the way. As China undergoes major structura...

Read
China’s polyethylene indigestion persists as margins point to major downturn
30/10/2019

By John Richardson CHINA’S POLYETHYLENE (PE) market continues to display signs of chronic indigest...

Read
China’s inland petrochemicals demand will never come anywhere close to coastal levels
28/10/2019

By John Richardson ONE DIMENSIONAL analysis of China would have you believe that as per capita incom...

Read
US ethylene glycols: Diversifying away from China may prove impossible
23/10/2019

By John Richardson US BUSINESSES are making arrangements to diversify their supply chains away from ...

Read
The US places heavy bets on LLDPE at a time of demand erosion
21/10/2019

By John Richardson IT IS a remarkably single product-focused strategy given the exposure of linear-l...

Read
China’s real GDP growth below 6% as mono-ethylene glycols margins provide early indicator of depth of downturn
18/10/2019

By John Richardson GLOBAL stock markets will now doubt respond negatively to the news that China’s...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more