ASIAN PE and PP spreads turned negative in October this year for the first time since the same month five years earlier. As spreads turned negative it seems certain that margins would have been in deeper negative territory as spreads don’t account for the full costs of production.

Back in October 2014 the sharp fall in oil prices had yet to benefit Asian polyolefins producers as they struggled to deal with a slowdown in the Chinese economy resulting from reduced lending.

Wind the clock forward to October of this year and producers were facing high oil prices and once again a slowdown in lending availability in China. This was combining with the negative effect on sentiment resulting from the US/China trade war.

You can argue, as John Kemp does in this persuasive Reuters article, that oil prices have reached a cyclical peak and will edge down over the next year.

Equally, though, a major geopolitical crisis or a collapse in financial and commodity markets could mean oil well in excess of $100/bbl or below $40/bbl over the next 12 months.

You need to plan for all these three oil price outcomes.

Extreme oil price and so naphtha feedstock cost uncertainty could occur during what I believe will be a global recession in 2019 on an acceleration in the US/China trade and Cold War war.

The global recession will also be triggered by the global economy hitting a wall of debt as interest rates continue to rise and as economic stimulus is withdrawn by all the major central banks.

Unlike in 2009, there will be no major coordination between the world’s central banks to limit the impact of the recession because of a.) The animus between the US, the rest of the West and China and b.) Competing political objectives within the EU.

The Asian PE industry will struggle to absorb the big increase in US production – especially if the US cannot export to China.

Smaller import markets such as Indonesia and Vietnam could end up being flooded by US material, with other major importers such as Europe and Turkey also under pressure. LLDPE will see the biggest US production increase in 2019, and so it is in this polymer where oversupply pressures will be the greatest.

Major shift in ethylene markets may also be a threat

The above chart shows the big change in Asian ethylene and PE markets from 2012 onwards (the chart only shows Northeast Asian ethylene prices and China PE prices, but the pattern is exactly the same in Southeast Asia).

In December 2002-December 2011, spreads between Northeast Asian ethylene and Japan naphtha averaged $379/tonne as spreads between ethylene and China PE averaged $182/tonne (December 2002 is the starting point for the graph, as this is when we began our China PE price assessments).

But from January 2012 until October this year there was a remarkable turnaround. Naphtha-to- ethylene spreads soared to $548/tonne with ethylene-to-PE spreads at just $32/tonne. And quite often, as the chart illustrates, ethylene-PE spreads were negative.

This reflects a very tight Asian spot ethylene market (the ethylene prices above are spot only). This has benefited PE producers because of the following:

  • Converters often look at ethylene-to-PE spreads and assume that they reflect the profitability of producers.
  • But in reality, nearly all Asian PE producers are integrated through to their own crackers or buy ethylene by pipeline at contract prices much cheaper than spot cargoes that are delivered by ship.
  • But because converters pay close attention to ethylene-to-PE spreads, the fall in spreads since January 2012 helped PE producers achieve price increases.
  • Cracker operators also boosted ethylene sales at times of strong naphtha-ethylene spreads. This further supported profitability.

The last few weeks have seen a collapse in Asian spot ethylene prices and thus spreads over naphtha. This has been the result of Middle East ethylene derivatives shutdowns while associated crackers have continued to run.

Some industry sources tell me that the Asian spot ethylene market will be longer over the next year as a result of increased deep-sea shipments. If this is correct then Asian PE producers will no longer be able to use high ethylene costs to justify increases in PE prices.

Geopolitics and macroeconomics reach a turning point

It is going to be a difficult 2019. Just how difficult depends on the extent to which polyolefins producers ignore the conventional thinking and plan for the new recession. Prudent feedstock purchasing strategies are clearly key, as are sensible sales growth targets for PE and PP.

So is positioning yourselves to take advantage of what looks likely to be a major shift in global trade. If the US is excluded from China over the long term, China will need to buy from elsewhere to meet its huge PE import needs. PP may, however, disappear as an export opportunity to China.

The task for Asian polyolefins producers isto manage their businesses carefully during the recession, to preserve cash, to minimise losses, while building stronger relationships with China, ready for when the recovery arrives.

PREVIOUS POST

President Trump’s “very good” call with President Xi: Nothing changes

02/11/2018

PRESIDENT TRUMP said yesterday that his discussions with President Xi Jinping we...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Major crude downside and upside risks for petchems

11/11/2018

By John Richardson ONE of the biggest risks for petrochemicals producers has onc...

Learn more
More posts
Global polyethylene in 2020: Margins will reach historic lows as new growth model emerges
08/12/2019

Here is a first of a series of outlook articles for 2020 where I focus on the risks ahead for the gl...

Read
Long term downcycle will transform global petrochemicals, creating new Winners and Losers
06/12/2019

By John Richardson THIS IS not a normal downcycle. Please get over that idea however many people, bo...

Read
Asian PE and PP margins at lowest levels in at least five years and will go lower……
04/12/2019

By John Richardson NOT since at least the beginning of 2014 have Northeast and Southeast Asian polye...

Read
Asian polypropylene market heads for major 2020 downturn
02/12/2019

By John Richardson THE ASIAN polypropylene (PP) market hasn’t been as bad as the region’s polyet...

Read
China new vehicle sales: A long term decline and what this means for petrochemicals
29/11/2019

By John Richardson THE MAINSTREAM view is that there is nothing fundamental about the decline in new...

Read
Asian copolymer polyproplyene used as a sink for growing oversupply of ethylene
27/11/2019

By John Richardson A SURE sign that the Asian ethylene-to-polyethylene (PE) markets are distressed c...

Read
Asian polyethylene shutdowns? Once again, good luck with that idea
25/11/2019

By John Richardson I was new to the game as I had only been analysing the petrochemicals business fo...

Read
Europe to become much more self-sufficient in polyethylene because of sustainability
20/11/2019

Yes, I know I promised to focus on Asia and its cracker-to-PE industry today and how the region will...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more