Investors worry US ethylene expansions mimic mining downturn

Chemical companies


US C2 Jul15I spent most of last week in New York and Boston, meeting with major investors.  One key topic on all their agendas was the major downturn underway in the global mining industry.  The connection with my visit was that some have already begun to worry that the planned US ethylene expansions may lead to a similar outcome.

The reason is that mining companies were a few years ahead of the US in rushing to boost their capacity by record amounts.  They were convinced that China’s growth would be sustained at double-digit levels forever. Now they are paying the price.  As the Financial Times reports:

“Commodity prices roared up during the past decade because of voracious demand from China, which single-handedly transformed the mining industry.  But prices have come down virtually across the board as China’s economic growth has slowed, and the country moved away from a multi-year construction boom.”

Equally sobering is the assessment of Mark Cutifani, chief executive of leading company, Anglo American,

It is a pretty tough market. The news from China hasn’t been good . . . It has deteriorated more than we expected and we think it is going to be tougher in the next six months“.

Investors are now worrying they may have encouraged US ethylene producers to make the same mistake:

  • They are currently helping to fund a 40+% increase in US ethylene capacity, at an estimated cost of $145bn
  • Yet as the chart above shows, the US has been unable to raise its demand above the levels of 10 years ago
  • Ethylene, PVC, styrene and ethylene glycol output peaked in 2004, and polyethylene output peaked in 2007

US PE Jul15Equally worrying is that net exports of ethylene’s major derivative, polyethylene, have been in decline since 2009, as the second chart based on data from Global Trade Information Services confirms,

Investors are also worried that many of these investments are apparently proceeding without the security of signed off-take contracts, backed by major bank guarantees.  This also mirrors developments in the mining industry, where euphoria over the outlook for China was the key driver.

These concerns are now being brought into sharp focus by the renewed weakness in crude oil prices since the Iran nuclear deal was finalised.  Investors are now concerned that if this decline continues, a return to lower oil prices could remove today’s US cost advantage versus other regions.  China’s stock market collapse adds to their concern.

These developments highlight the way that investors’ rose-tinted glasses led to them falling in love with the shale gas story, just as they had with mining.  They had encouraged both industries to expand by bidding up share prices for the companies involved, and rushing to provide the necessary finance.  Now they are realising, too late, that different Scenarios were also possible.

There is, of course, no easy escape from the current commitments, given the up-front costs that have already been incurred.  But the example of the mining industry suggests cancellation may well end up being the lowest cost option in the long run.



China’s collapsing stock market underlines need for New Normal reforms


My latest post for the Financial Times, published on the BeyondBrics blog is ...

Learn more

US housing sees major change as middle-market is squeezed


US house prices have recovering for 3 years, as the chart from the Wall Street J...

Learn more
More posts
Chemicals in the eye of the storm as UK heads for a WTO Brexit on 1 January

On Friday, the UK premier confirmed what many of us have expected for a long time. There is unlikely...

Chemical industry has key role in helping to create a more sustainable world

The chemical industry has a critical role to play in enabling the world to “build back better&...

Local circular plastics solutions to replace mega projects business model

NEW YORK (ICIS)–There will be a paradigm shift away from mega crackers producing massive volum...

Reshoring set to create Winners and Losers as advanced manufacturing takes over

Not many companies still operate in the same way as 500 years ago, or even 50 years ago. But in manu...

Polyethylene’s crisis will create Winners and Losers

Polyethylene markets (PE) are moving into a crisis, with margins in NE Asia already negative, as I h...

Day of reckoning approaches for US polyethylene expansions, and the European industry

Planning for future demand in petrochemicals and polymers used to be relatively easy during the Baby...

Stormy weather ahead for chemicals

Four serious challenges are on the horizon for the global petrochemical industry as I describe in my...

Ethane price hikes, China tariffs, hit US PE producers as global market weakens

Sadly, my July forecast that US-China tariffs could lead to a global polyethylene price war seems to...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more