‘Slow motion’ Greek train wreck gets ready to hit another buffer

Uncategorized

SHARE THIS STORY

Train wreck1The key issue in the Greek debt crisis is easy to understand,.  It is that Greece’s GDP last year was just $238bn, whilst its debts are estimated at €322bn ($365bn).   So Greece is clearly going to default at some point.  The problem is that no policymaker is prepared to admit this obvious fact, as they are frightened of what might happen as a result:

  • The German and other Eurozone governments are terrified that their electorates might discover they are in line to pay the bill for Greece defaulting on its debts.  The German part of the bill could easily be €86bn, and in a worst case could be the entire €322bn according to the respected IFO Institute
  • The Greek government is also terrified that it will be thrown out of office if it doesn’t follow through on its recent election promises to end austerity, and establish a European version of Roosevelt’s New Deal

Meanwhile, everyone outside the negotiations stays calm, because they assume that in the end, both sides will agree another ‘pretend and extend’ deal that avoids the need to tackle the key issue.

January 2009 saw the first signs of trouble, when Greece’s credit rating was downgraded.  The shock of the financial crisis meant some people now realised debt had to be repaid, and couldn’t just be rolled-over forever.

By May 2010, the first Greek ‘rescue package’ had been agreed.  At the time, I followed the example of investment manager Jeremy Grantham in describing it as a train crash:

In July 2007, he coined the term ‘slow motion train wreck’ to describe the coming Crisis. And back in August 2008, the Financial Times helpfully pointed out that in economic crashes “there are pauses before the next carriage hits the one in front“. It added that “this explains how we have since moved from crisis to crisis, with rallies in between, as participants persuade themselves that the worst is over.”

At the time, the cost of restructuring Greece’s economy was supposed to be just €30bn in government cuts, and €110bn of loans from the Eurozone and the IMF.  But one warning sign was that even this level of cuts was going to keep Greece in recession till 2017.

And so in July 2011, 21% of Greece’s then €350bn debts had to be written off.

But by May 2012, it was clear this had been “too little, too late“.  Greece’s debt had apparently reached €400bn – whilst GDP had fallen 20% since 2008.  At this stage, many began to lose faith in the published numbers for the debt.

But the political leaders pressed on with the ‘pretend and extend’ concept.  Put simply, the lenders told Greece to ‘pretend’ it would repay the loans: in return, they promised to ‘extend’ repayment out as far as 2050.

ECONOMIC AND MONETARY UNION CANNOT WORK WITHOUT POLITICAL UNION
The core issue is that Greece was a poor country when it joined rich countries such as Germany in the Eurozone in 1999.  Its GDP/capita was just $11k.  Only full political union could have made this a workable arrangement – with the precedent being the deal between the two Germanies after the fall of the Berlin Wall.

Back in 1990, when the concept of the euro was first discussed, political union was indeed high on the agenda.  German Chancellor Kohl and French President Mitterand publicly agreed it was essential that to hold “an intergovernmental conference on political union” alongside that proposed for economic and monetary union.

But of course this never happened.  In the end, France refused to surrender its national sovereignty.  In turn, Germany refused to move forward without having central controls in place to control tax and spending policies.

So instead, everyone decided to pretend that political union existed.  And the banks (often state-owned) lent large sums to poor EU members such as Greece, assuming that Germany would pay the bill if something went wrong.

Needless to say, this was the worst possible option.  The banks lent, and the Greeks spent, but nothing was done to ensure repayment was possible.  It was classic ‘Ponzi Lending’ as defined by Hyman Minsky.

PRETEND AND EXTEND HAS MADE A BAD SITUATION WORSE – FOR EVERYONE
And then in 2012, the ‘pretend and extend’ policy made a bad situation even worse.

In a corporate bankruptcy, the lenders have to sit down with management and either agree to closure, or to refinance. Refinancing usually means swapping the debt for equity, and then putting in new money to help the company rebuild for the future.  But this has never happened with Greece:

  • Instead, the new money it received went largely to repay the German and other banks who had made the loans
  • Very little new money went to rebuild the Greek economy
  • Understandably, the government therefore gave only paper commitments on tax, pension and other reforms
  • In addition, a delayed repayment schedule was agreed, in some cases out to 2050
  • This meant the other Eurozone governments could pretend to their electorates that their money was safe

One obvious lesson from the crisis is that we lack leaders who are prepared to stand up and speak the truth to their voters.  Instead, they prefer to hide behind the “figleaf” of monetary policy and pretend everything will soon be fine.

So it would be no surprise if another deal emerges again this time.  But this will not solve the Greek problem.  It will just increase the debt still further until one day, something finally upsets the ‘pretend and extend’ policy.

When the Greek domino finally falls, the lenders will in turn be unable to pay their debts.  I fear a most unpleasant reality may then follow the game of ‘pretend and extend’.

PREVIOUS POST

Bank of Japan admits stimulus policy is modelled on Peter Pan

09/06/2015

The key issue in the Greek debt crisis is easy to understand,.  It is that Gree...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China auto sales rise just 1% as New Normal slowdown bites

11/06/2015

The key issue in the Greek debt crisis is easy to understand,.  It is that Gree...

Learn more
More posts
$60bn opportunity opens up for plastics industry as need to eliminate single-use packaging grows
17/03/2019

150 businesses representing over 20% of the global plastic packaging market have now agreed to start...

Read
Ageing Perennials set to negate central bank stimulus as recession approaches
10/03/2019

The world’s best leading indicator for the global economy is still firmly signalling recession...

Read
Déjà vu all over again for oil markets as recession risks rise
03/03/2019

Back in 2015, veteran Saudi Oil Minister Ali  Naimi was very clear about Saudi’s need to adop...

Read
BASF prepares its UK supply chain for Brexit
24/02/2019

BASF has been working with Ready for Brexit (the online platform I co-founded last year) as part of ...

Read
Companies and investors have just 30 working days left to prepare for a No Deal Brexit
17/02/2019

Companies across the UK and EU27 are suddenly realising there are now just 30 working days until the...

Read
The BoE’s pre-emptive strike is not without risk
12/02/2019

The Financial Times has kindly printed my letter below, arguing that it seems the default answer to ...

Read
IKEA heads into the circular world with furniture subscription trial
10/02/2019

“Once upon a time, Granny and Grandad used to go to a large shop on the motorway to buy their ...

Read
Fed’s magic money tree hopes to overcome smartphone sales downturn and global recession risk
03/02/2019

Last November, I wrote one of my “most-read posts”, titled Global smartphone recession ...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more