Eurozone politicians have built a Tower of Babel



Tower of Babel.pngLast week saw the 20th EU ‘Crisis Summit’. Like the previous 19, it achieved little. Yet everyone at the meeting knew what had to be agreed:

• A banking union which operates across national borders
• The issuing of joint Eurozone bonds, guaranteed by all euro members
• Adoption of a Federal budget and economic policy

These measures would create the essential fiscal union required to support the euro as a common currency.

Equally, this is not a new debate. It was spelt out in 1990 by German Chancellor Kohl and French President Mitterand, when the concept of the euro was first discussed. As the US example shows, monetary and fiscal union also requires political union.

But today, the two countries at the heart of the euro project are as far away as ever from agreement:

• Germany wants to have central controls over spending
• But France will not agree to give up national sovereignty.

Equally, as Reuters notes, the leaders continue to talk different economic and political languages. The ‘crisis summits’ thus resemble the efforts to build the biblical Tower of Babel, pictured above by Breughel.

Thus in German, the word for ‘debt’ is Schuld, which also means ‘guilt’.

So in Germany, the Eurozone debate is a morality play, where those in debt are ‘sinners’:

• It wants the debtor countries to introduce a stability culture of low inflation and low debt, via a savings policy based on austerity
• But new French President Hollande won election on the basis of a ‘growth policy’ based on spending, not savings.

Pensions policy highlights the difference. Germany is raising pension ages to 67 years. Whilst France has just reduced them from 62 to 60 years.

The European Central Bank is caught in the middle. It provided €1tn ($1.4tn) of emergency funding in December to avoid the collapse of the banking system. But it cannot force the politicians to accept the need for fiscal and political union to support monetary union.

Thus as the blog warned a year ago:

“The alternative (to agreement) is not the status quo, as too many politicians still hope. It is that the Eurozone could eventually break up, and in the process severely damage both the European Union and the wider global economy.”


Most pension funds have negative returns since 2007


The chart above should be of great interest to anyone who hopes to retire on a p...

Learn more

IMF warns of lower global growth


Once again, the chemical industry has performed its role as a reliable leading i...

Learn more
More posts
Brexit a disaster for the UK, Europe and the world

First, the good news.  It has long been recognised that the UK economy is over-dependent on financi...

UK’s May election will create major political and economic uncertainty

Nobody can guess the outcome of the UK’s general election on 7 May.  This is astonishing, as ...

Great Unwinding of policymaker stimulus creates interest rate risk

Interest rate risk is rising in the developed economies as the Great Unwinding of policymaker stim...

“Disaster is still some way off” for Cyprus, as Germany prepares to vote

Back in April, the blog suggested that capital controls might remain for rather longer in Cyprus tha...

Global interest rates surge as Newton’s 3rd Law continues to operate

Newton’s 3rd Law of Motion states, “To every action there is always an equal and opposit...

“A word means just what I choose it to mean”

‘When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just...

The Eurozone train crash heads for the buffers

For 25 years, Western policymakers coasted to electoral success on the back of an economic Supercycl...

Leaving the Eurozone would be very difficult

Last December, the blog raised the question of how a country like Greece could actually leave the Eu...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more