5 Risks to China’s growth story

Economic growth


Lewis curve WSJ.pngChina’s economic growth has become more and more unbalanced over the past 10 years, as we discussed in chapter 6 of Boom, Gloom and the New Normal. Its domestic consumption is now only around a third of GDP, compared to 50% a decade ago. Instead, the leadership has focused on achieving growth via exports and infrastructure investment.

This ‘short-cut’ to higher growth is now looking more and more like a dead-end. Exports are falling, as the ageing Western babyboomers cut back their spending. Whilst the surge in bank lending has often led to purely speculative activity, such as the housing market bubble.

Now, not for the first time, China’s leadership are flagging that they may move away from their GDP-driven policies. Bloomberg report premier Wen may announce a GDP target of less than 8% in his National People’s Congress speech on 5 March. The problem is that the move, if it comes, may well be ‘too little, too late’ to put China back on course.

Wen himself recognised the issue 5 years ago, when he described the economy as being “unstable, unbalanced, uncoordinated and unsustainable“. But hard choices were deferred when the financial crisis hit in Q4 2008. Instead, lax lending made the problems worse, not better.

Policymakers discussed a possible new approach at December’s economic work conference, which highlighted that “the country is poised to make some significant policy changes”. As Yi Xianrong of China’s Academy of Social Sciences noted then:

“The country has shown more determination than ever to shy away from any enormous economic stimulus packages in an endeavor to decelerate its fast pace of GDP growth”.

‘Better late than never’ is probably the sensible response to this potential policy change. But unwinding the legacy of the previous past decade will not be easy, and creates 5 major risks:

• China’s current policy saw its share of global exports hit 10.5% in 2011, up from 8.8% in 2007. Replacing this volume, and the jobs it created, will not be easy
• Similarly, its wasteful infrastructure investment, which rose to 48% of GDP in 2011 from 42% in 2007 means money has been spent which cannot be recovered
• China’s new short-cut to help boost consumption is to increase wages by 13% a year. But this will reduce profit margins and jobs
• It is also difficult for any country to manage a smooth transition on such a scale. There is a strong risk that the uncertainty created may reduce future investment spending
• Finally, there is the really big risk, that China may hit the ‘middle income trap’ we described, and simply fail to make the transition required

This latter risk is not just the blog’s concern. Yesterday, the World Bank and China’s Development Research Center (DRC) published their major China 2030 report which warned explicitly that:

“China’s growth is in danger of decelerating rapidly and without much warning. That is what has occurred with other highflying developing countries, such as Brazil and Mexico, once they reached a certain income level, a phenomenon that economists call the ‘middle-income trap’.”

The chart above, from the Wall Street Journal, highlights the scale of this risk. The blue columns show GDP/capita pre-1970 in countries including China, Thailand, Malaysia, S Korea and Japan. The orange column updates this to the 2007/9 average. Some countries have clearly done very well. Korea, for example, has moved from having a GDP/capita of only 10% of US levels to almost 60% today.

Following Korea’s example will not be easy for China. The blog was a regular visitor to Korea in the 1987-92 period, when a key part of this transition took place. It saw major political change taking place, as ordinary people were allowed to vote for their president in a direct secret ballot. This will not be happening later this year in China, when President Hu is expected to be replaced by Vice President Xi.

Yet as Sir Arthur Lewis’ work has shown, political change of this kind is essential if the economy is to continue to grow. Equally, China’s ‘one child policy’ means it has no choice – it cannot continue to rely on cheap labour, and has to become more capital intensive.

The World Bank/DRC report highlights the key question. Can China manage this transition? Equally, it warns that “A sharp slowdown could deepen problems in the Chinese banking sector and elsewhere, and could prompt a crisis“.


Demand declines as Federal Reserve fuels oil price rise


The Wall Street Journal carried an interesting opinion piece on Friday, assessin...

Learn more

The changing landscape for manufacturers


The New Normal involves three major transformations in the nature of consumer ma...

Learn more
More posts
Pandemic redraws the map

  Companies have entered a new landscape where the coronavirus has accelerated major paradigm s...

What will happen if President Trump loses the election?

I spent from September 2015 onwards, during the last US Presidential election, trying to explain why...

Covid fears risk a Great Depression and major social unrest

Governments spent most of February/March ignoring my warnings here on the dangers posed by the Covid...

The state of the global economy in 2020

Last Wednesday, I gave the opening presentation for the ICIS PET Conference and looked at whether th...

Reality dawns for business as No Deal Brexit approaches

I warned before the June 2016 Brexit referendum that Brexit was all about politics, and Boris Johnso...

Global chemical industry – key trends for success in today’s New Normal

The chemical industry is the best leading indicator for the global economy. On Friday, I had the pri...

Oil prices signal potential end to the V-shaped recovery myth

Oil prices have moved into another ‘flag shape’ – which previously provided critic...

Bankruptcies now the key risk as hopes for V-shaped recovery disappear

Governments, financial markets and central banks all originally assumed the Covid-19 pandemic would ...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more