The real challenge is a lack of challenge

Economic growth

SHARE THIS STORY

EmperorWe all remember the Hans Christian Andersen story about the Emperor with no clothes.  His subjects were told that only those who were stupid or incompetent would be unable to see his wonderful new suit.

Of course, nobody wanted to appear stupid or incompetent.  So when the Emperor paraded in his new clothes, nobody wanted to tell him the obvious.  It was left to a child to cry out, “But he isn’t wearing anything at all!”

The story has been translated into over a hundred languages.  But it seems its message has not been learnt by the iron ore industry.

It has vastly over-expanded in the mistaken belief that China would continue buying more and more iron forever and ever.  A child, of course, could have told them this was unlikely.  But these days, highly-paid CEOs travel in private jets, and never have to meet children.  So they suffer, no matter how brilliant, from a lack of challenge.

Thus the Top 5 iron ore producers – Rio Tinto, BHP Billiton,Vale, Anglo-American and Fortescue –  are continuing to expand production even though the outlook for demand growth continues to weaken in China, their main market.  As the Wall Street Journal notes:

  • China imports two-thirds of internationally traded iron ore
  • One quarter of the world’s iron ore is new production
  • Global output from the Top 5 will grow 40% by 2017 to 1.5bn tonnes

Of course, the miners’ CEOs are not stupid.  Thus the CEO of Anglo-American recognises that demand will slow:

China will not spend what it has been spending on infrastructure.There are still plenty of buildings with no one in them”

LOW-COST IS NO LONGER A GUARANTEE OF FUTURE SUCCESS
Instead, the problem is the lack of challenge.  Nobody at senior levels dares to say the obvious, that this is going to be a major disaster and needs to be stopped now.  Instead, groupthink takes over, and they convince themselves that someone else will shutdown.Iron ore Sept14

Yet a moment’s research would show that low-cost on its own is no guarantee of profitability in an over-supplied market.  Large companies rarely shutdown because of cost issues:

  • Even if they go bankrupt, there is always a new investor prepared to pay pennies on the dollar for a punt that things might get better
  • And failing that, governments will often nationalise the operation to preserve jobs and tax revenues

Plus, of course, much of the assumed demand in China has been fictional.  As the blog’s ‘Your Compass on China’ Research Note highlighted in June, more than 100 million tonnes of iron ore is currently in bonded warehouses in China, being used as collateral to finance the housing bubble.  That is 10% of the current market, on its own.

Thus it is wishful thinking by the producers to imagine that someone else will rescue them from their ill-advised investments.  As the chart shows, prices have already more than halved from their peak.

But prices are still more than five times the level of 10 years ago.  And so the logical direction is for them to continue downwards, by a long way, as it is most unlikely that Chinese developments will make them profitable.

Why should Chinese plants shutdown on economic grounds?  China’s declared policy is “socialism with Chinese characteristics”.  And it will not allow jobs to be lost if this means its government might lose power due to social unrest.

Already a Reuters analysis suggests local government and other subsidies were responsible for four-fifths of reported H1 profits in China’s steel industry.

This leads the blog to wonder whether someone needs to arrange for a classroom of children to point this out to mining company investors instead?

 

PREVIOUS POST

Russian downturn causes GM, Ford U-turn; EU slows despite discounts

18/09/2014

We all remember the Hans Christian Andersen story about the Emperor with no c...

Learn more
NEXT POST

US ethylene outages boost European and Asian PE producers

22/09/2014

We all remember the Hans Christian Andersen story about the Emperor with no c...

Learn more
More posts
US-China trade war confirms political risk is now a key factor for companies and the economy
12/05/2019

There are few real surprises in life, and President Trump’s decision to launch a full-scale tr...

Read
Uber’s $91bn IPO marks the top for today’s debt-fuelled stock markets
28/04/2019

Uber’s IPO next month is set to effectively “ring the bell” at the top of the post...

Read
The End of “Business as Usual”
21/04/2019

In my interview for Real Vision earlier this month, (where the world’s most successful invest...

Read
Most businesses were nowhere near Ready for Brexit last Friday – we mustn’t make the same mistake again
14/04/2019

Thank goodness for backbench MPs and the European Union. Without their efforts, the UK would by now ...

Read
Don’t get carried away by Beijing’s stimulus
07/04/2019

Residential construction work in Qingdao, China. Government stimulus is unlikely to deliver the econ...

Read
Businesses thrilled by Brexit uncertainty: “It’s exhilarating” says small business owner
01/04/2019

With the European Commission saying that a No Deal is now “likely“, small businesses acr...

Read
Ageing Perennials set to negate central bank stimulus as recession approaches
10/03/2019

The world’s best leading indicator for the global economy is still firmly signalling recession...

Read
BASF prepares its UK supply chain for Brexit
24/02/2019

BASF has been working with Ready for Brexit (the online platform I co-founded last year) as part of ...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more