China sees $13.5bn of fake September ‘collateral trade’ invoices

Financial Events

SHARE THIS STORY

China PE Oct14China’s ‘collateral trade’ is still a major force in world markets for iron ore, copper and even plastics such as polyethylene.  September’s data suggests $13.5bn of fake invoices added 56% to the value of China’s exports to Hong Kong, as property developers strove to raise cash to finish their buildings.

Full details of the trade are given in our June Research Note, and you can read a quick summary here.  There are 2 major reasons why it matters so much:

  • Investors had thought China’s vast imports of copper and iron were due to its rapid industrialisation.  But it is now clear that much of the volume has instead funded speculation in China’s housing bubble
  • China’s government is now aware of the problem.  It has identified increasing amounts of fraud and is investigating the fake invoice problem.  As a result, Letters of Credit have become hard to obtain

What does this mean for you and me?  It means that companies have made a terrible mistake by expanding capacity to supply apparent demand in China.  Not only does this new production have no home to go to.  But all the product sitting on China’s docksides has no home either.

I simply cannot see any way in which this story does not end badly.  The only questions are around exactly when the end comes, and how bad it is.  Clearly, it could be very bad indeed, and I fear the Worst Case Scenario identified back in June risks becoming ever more probable.

Developments in plastics markets are only a small part of the story.  But trying to unravel them seems valuable, as their smaller scale helps to make the bigger picture easier to understand.

THE PE IMPORT SURGE SEEMS TO HAVE BEEN BASED ON THE ‘COLLATERAL TRADE’
The chart above identifies the key problem, namely the impossibly large rise in China’s apparent polyethylene (PE) demand this year.  Data from Global Trade Information Services shows:

  • Demand apparently surged 22% this year (red column) versus 2012 (blue column), with imports up 20%
  • Production also rose 22%, in line with increases for polypropylene (up 24%) and PVC (up 19%)
  • But China’s PP imports have actually fallen 2% over the same period, and it has become a net exporter of PVC
  • Why would PE suddenly require a 20% increase in imports?

The only rational explanation is that imports have been used as collateral to finance property market speculation.

The really worrying point is that it seems this game may be coming to an end.  China’s housing market is slowing fast, with prices falling in 69 of 70 cities last month.  So PE producers and consumers, like those in metals markets, now need to worry about what happens next.

They are the innocent victims.  But being innocent will not help if, as seems more and more likely, there is a disorderly unwinding of China’s “collateral trade”.   Where will all this stored volume go, and what will happen to global prices?

Self-preservation means companies must urgently develop a strategy to deal with this risk.  Waiting until it happens will be too late

PREVIOUS POST

China becomes major PVC, PTA exporter for first time in history

28/10/2014

Be very careful what you wish for.  That is the key message coming out of close...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Global auto sales reach 'top of the mountain' moment

30/10/2014

The best view is always from the top of the mountain.  And that seems where we ...

Learn more
More posts
China’s property sector is at the epicentre of the crisis
29/03/2020

A branch of Centaline Property Agency in Hong Kong © Bloomberg Indebted Chinese property developers...

Read
“They may ring their bells now, before long they will be wringing their hands”
15/03/2020

The wisdom of Sir Robert Walpole, the UK’s first premier, seems the only possible response to ...

Read
Will stock markets see a Minsky Moment in 2020?
05/01/2020

Few investors now remember the days when price discovery was thought to be the key role of stock mar...

Read
Chart of the Decade – the Fed’s support for the S&P 500 will end with a debt crisis
22/12/2019

Each year, there has been only one possible candidate for Chart of the Year.  Last year it was the ...

Read
$50bn hole appears in New York financial markets – Fed is “looking into it”
29/09/2019

Most people would quickly notice if $50 went missing from their purse or wallet. They would certainl...

Read
China’s renminbi and the global ring of fire
01/09/2019

China’s property bubble puts it at the epicentre of the ring of fire © Reuters  China’s de...

Read
Stock markets risk Wile E. Coyote fall despite Powell’s rush to support the S&P 500
06/01/2019

How can companies and investors avoid losing money as the global economy goes into a China-led reces...

Read
Why everyone ignored my warnings ahead of the financial crisis
16/09/2018

It’s 10 years since my forecast of a global financial crisis came true, as Lehman Brothers col...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more