Default or debt forgiveness the options in Greek elections

Economic growth


AlchemistWithin our mandate, the ECB is ready to do whatever it takes to preserve the euro. And believe me, it will be enough”.  That was the statement by European Central Bank head Mario Draghi in July 2012, where he aimed to draw a line under the Eurozone debt crisis.

Yet here we are in December 2014, and the crisis is back again and likely to become worse.

The problem, as I have argued since September 2011, is that current central bank policies are simply a modern form of medieval alchemy, and cannot possibly solve the debt problem:

Alchemists have always claimed to be able to perform the impossible.  The most common claim was that they could turn lead into gold.  In Europe, the European Central Bank has been trying the same trick.  It claimed to turn near-worthless Greek bonds into German-quality euros.  Now its German board member Jürgen Stark has followed German Bundesbank president Axel Weber in resigning over the issue.  The reason is obvious:

  • The ECB action can only work for a short period
  • Greece, as the blog has argued since May 2010, will never be able to pay its bills
  • Germany will then end up paying the bill, when it is finally agreed that lead is not gold”

And since then, Greece’s situation has become far worse.  Youth unemployment is now above 50%, whilst its economy has shrunk by a quarter since the crisis began.

Unsurprisingly, therefore, its pro-austerity government was finally forced to resign this week.  Elections are due on 25 January, with the populist party, Syriza, currently ahead in opinion polls.  Their declared policy is to write off around half of Greece’s foreign debt – leaving Germany to pay the bill.

The real tragedy is that Europe’s political elite still continue to believe that their alchemy can magically create economic growth.  They refuse to accept the logic of common sense that Europe’s ageing BabyBoomer population make it  impossible to return to the Boomer-led levels of SuperCycle growth.

Instead we need new policies, as suggested yesterday in an excellent article by John Plender in the Financial Times.  One key issue is that the German word for debt, Schuld, also means ‘guilt’.  As he writes:

The logical way forward is debt forgiveness. Yet a moralistic perception of creditors as inherently virtuous and debtors as profligate sinners stands in the way (no matter that such “profligates” as Spain and Ireland entered the crisis with government debt way below the German level). So, too, does a selective German historical memory.

“The paradox of the German view on debt is that Germany has been the biggest developed world beneficiary of debt forgiveness in recent memory. In the postwar London Debt Agreement, German external debt was substantially written off or deferred. The West German economic miracle was thus launched from a clean balance sheet while the Allies remained heavily indebted.”

Deflation is inevitable in the Eurozone, as the oil price falls.  This will make it even more difficult for today’s debt to be repaid.  Printing more money as the ECB now propose will simply increase debt levels, making a bad situation worse.

In turn, this will enable populist parties such as Syriza to build on their success in last May’s European elections.


Chart of the Year - China's auto sales bubble begins to burst


‘How China fooled the world’ was the subject of an excellent BBC doc...

Learn more

G7 births in 2013 equal Great Depression year of 1933


In 2013, there were fewer births in the G7 countries – responsible for ne...

Learn more
More posts
The Fed’s stock market bubble is at risk as China bursts its real estate bubble

The US stock market bubble just keeps rising. And every investor “knows” that the US Fed...

EU patience starts to run out as UK threatens to break the N Ireland Protocol

Unsurprisingly, it turns out that Brexit still isn’t “oven-ready”, despite the UK ...

An end to the China bubble would risk a Minsky moment

My letter in today’s Financial Times warning of the risk to Western financial markets from the bur...

Xi aims to “bring order out of chaos” by bursting China’s property bubble

China is at the start of its biggest economic shake-up since 1978, when Deng Xiaoping launched his p...

Housing markets face long-term downturn as central banks abandon stimulus

Last month saw the beginning of the end for the central banks’ 20-year experiment with stimulu...

Businesses set for transformation as supply chain chaos combines with Net Zero targets

‘Business as usual’ seems a most unlikely outcome as we look forward over the next 6 months....

Auto industry provides a model for the transition to Net Zero

Flooding in China and Europe, record temperatures in the USA, wild fires – all these are signs...

Europe’s Green Deal will transform its economy, as floods confirm urgency of tackling climate change

The floods raging in Germany and Benelux highlight the scale of the Climate Change challenge ahead....


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more