China’s lending bubble sees Beijing home prices jump 63%

Consumer demand

SHARE THIS STORY

China lend v auto Apr17Greed and fear are the primary emotions driving China’s housing and auto markets today, as China’s lending bubble hits new heights.  For ordinary citizens, greed is the key driver:

   Average home prices in Beijing rose an eye-popping 63% between October 2015 – February 2017
   In Shanghai, one enterprising estate agent (realtor) has married 4 of his clients to enable them to buy a home

Mr Wang’s story highlights the bubble mentality that has taken over the market.  As the Daily Telegraph reports, 30-year old Mr Wang:

Married, and then quickly divorced 4 women to allow them to circumvent strict property laws which seek to cool prices in China’s booming cities, and pocketed more than £8000 ($10k) from each transaction. Once the paperwork is put through, Wang applies for a divorce and puts himself on the market again”.

This is just the latest phase of a market craze, as I noted in November, when one Shenzhen resident told the South China Morning Post:

“The only thing I know is that buying property will not turn out to be a loss. From several thousand yuan a square metre to more than 100,000 yuan. Did it ever fall? Nope.”  He and his wife got divorced in February, in order to buy a 4th apartment in Shanghai for 3.6m yuan (US$530k) on the basis that “ If we don’t buy this apartment, we’ll miss the chance to get rich.”

A collective delusion has swept China’s Tier 1 cities, just as happened in the USA during the sub-prime bubble. Amazingly, China’s property bubble is even larger than sub-prime. Unremarkable pieces of land in Shanghai are now being sold at $2000/sq foot ($21500/sq metre), nearly 3 times the average land price in Manhattan, New York.

It is understandable in some ways, as Chinese buyers have never known a downturn, as I noted in September:

“It is also easy to forget that housing was all state-owned until 1998, and still is in most rural areas.  Urban housing was built and allocated by the state – and there wasn’t even a word for “mortgage” in the Chinese language.  Not only have home-buyers never lived through a major house price collapse, they have also had few other places to invest their money”.

The scale is also much larger, as UBS have reported:

“Chinese banks’ outstanding loans extended to the property industry were between Rmb 54tn – Rmb 72 tn in 2016 ($7.8tn – $10.4tn).”

The chart above confirms this analysis.  In reality, the key driver for the bubble has been the growth in lending.  As with the US subprime bubble, this has not only impacted housing markets, but also auto sales:

   Q1 lending (Total Social Financing) averaged Rmb 2.4tn/month, 2.2x the Rmb 700bn/month level in Q1 2008
   Q1 auto sales averaged 1.9 million, 2.06x the 733k/month average in Q1 2008

China’s GDP was only $11.2tn last year, meaning that its property sector loans are more than 2/3rds of GDP.

China incomes Apr17The problem is that everyone loves a bubble while it lasts.  And so, as in the US during subprime, most analysts are keen to argue that “everything is fine, nothing to worry about here”.

   In the US, we were told at the peak of the bubble in 2005 by then Federal Reserve Chairman, Alan Greenspan, that house prices would never fall on a national basis
  Today, similar wishful thinking dominates, based on the myth that China has suddenly developed a vast middle class, with Western levels of incomes

The problem, of course, as the second chart shows, is that this is also not true.  Annual disposable income for city-dwellers averaged just $5061 last year, whilst in rural areas it averaged only $1861.  You really don’t buy many homes or cars with that level of income, unless a massive lending bubble is underway.

And this is why fear is the right emotion for everyone outside China.  Its lending bubble has driven the “recovery” in global growth since 2009 – pushing up values of everything from homes to oil prices.  So anyone who remembers the end of the US subprime bubble should be very scared about what could happen when – not if – China’s bubble bursts.

We can all hope that President Xi’s new policies will enable a “soft landing” to occur, and gently unwind the stimulus policies put in place by Populist Premier Li and his predecessor Premier Wen?  But hope is not a strategy.  And as the Guardian reported last month:

“Goldman Sachs is said to estimate the chance of a financial crisis in China this year at 25%, and in 2018 at 50%.

 

PREVIOUS POST

Trump, Xi have 100 days to avert US-China trade war

12/04/2017

Last week’s summit meeting between US President Donald Trump and ChinaR...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Half of India's youth prioritise religion over science, and believe women should always listen to their husbands

20/04/2017

Mention India to many CEOs and investors, and they will smile broadly at the tho...

Learn more
More posts
Brand-owners start to focus on renewable carbon
13/06/2021

The original debate on plastics recycling owed its prominence to Ellen MacArthur, the yachtswoman wh...

Read
“One size no longer fits all” as the global smartphone market breaks down into different segments
30/05/2021

The pandemic was very good news for some companies, with demand for online activities rocketing. But...

Read
Biden’s Earth Day Summit puts plastics recycling on the fast track
25/04/2021

Plastics has long been the ‘odd one out’ in terms of recycling. Steel, aluminium, glass,...

Read
Americans hunker down on spending as the pandemic’s impact continues
11/04/2021

US stock markets have been hitting new records recently, as investors swoon over the idea that the $...

Read
Circular economy set to replace today’s broken global supply chains
21/03/2021

The Great Freeze in Texas has confirmed once again the problems with today’s global supply cha...

Read
Smartphone sales highlight new trends in consumer markets
07/02/2021

Smartphone markets continue to provide early warning of the major changes taking place in consumer m...

Read
Buyers scramble for product as global supply chains breakdown
24/01/2021

Asian LNG prices reached $32.50/MMBTU this month, up from less than $2/MMBTU in June. The Shanghai C...

Read
5 key questions for success in the New Normal
17/01/2021

Sustainability rather than globalisation is becoming the key driver for business. And the paradigm s...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more