US GDP growth stalls with participation rates near all-time low

Economic growth

SHARE THIS STORY

US GDP Apr17US GDP growth is slowing, again, as the chart of the Atlanta Federal Reserve’s “GDP Now” forecast shows:

   Forecast Q1 growth has slipped to just 0.6% from an initial 3.4% at the end of January
   Consensus economic forecasts are still much higher, but even they have fallen to 1.7% from 2.2%

The decline has been accelerating, due to disappointing data from a range of key indicators. as the Atlanta Fed note:

“The forecast for first-quarter real GDP growth fell 0.4% after the light vehicle sales release from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis and the ISM Non-Manufacturing Report On Business from the Institute for Supply Management on Wednesday and 0.2% after the employment release from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and the wholesale trade release from the U.S. Census Bureau this morning. Since April 4, the forecasts for first-quarter real consumer spending growth and real nonresidential equipment investment growth have fallen from 1.2% and 9.7% to 0.6% and 5.6% respectively.”

Worryingly, therefore, we seem to be repeating the usual pattern of disappointment – with New Year optimism being followed by harsh reality – as the US Federal Reserve’s deputy chairman, Stanley Fischer, noted nearly 3 years ago:

“Year after year we have had to explain from mid-year on why the global growth rate has been lower than predicted as little as two quarters back.

US jobs Apr17

The key issue, of course, is that policymakers have still not accepted that the US economy is inevitably moving into a low-growth mode, due to its ageing population.  As the Chief Economist of the Bank of England, Andy Haldane noted recently, the impact of:

“Demographics in mainstream economics has been under-emphasized for too long

There is little sign of the new policies that are urgently required to take account of the changes that have taken place in life expectancy and fertility rate.  As a result, forecasts continue to be made on the basis of wishful thinking at the start of each New Year. As I noted in December:

□  Increasing life expectancy means people no longer routinely die around pension age. Instead, a whole New Old generation of people in the low spending, low earning 55+ generation is emerging for the first time in history. The average western BabyBoomer can now expect to live for another 20 years on reaching the age of 65
□  Fertility rates in the developed world have fallen by 40% since 1950. They have also been below replacement levels (2.1 babies per woman) for the past 45 years. Inevitably, therefore, this has reduced the relative numbers of those in today’s Wealth Creator cohort, just as the New Old generation is expanding exponentially

Friday’s US jobs numbers confirmed this obvious truth, as the second chart shows:

 Less than 2/3rds of the US over-16s population now have jobs.  The current percentage of 62.9% is back at 1978 levels – when the median age was 30 years, compared to today’s 38 years – and so relatively more young people were still in school and college
□  The picture for men is particularly worrying, with just 68.9% at work, an all-time low.  The dcline seems to have accelerated since the Finanical Crisis began, with the participation rate falling from 73.2% in 2007
□   The percentage of women working is also still in decline, although at a slower rate.  It is at 57.2% today compared to the 60% peak in 1999 before Boomer women began to retire

US jobs Apr17aEven more worrying is the data shown on the 3rd chart, which highlights the changes in real wages, adjusted for inflation, since records began in 1979:

□    Average earnings in 2016 were only just higher than in 2009, at $347/week versus $345/week
□    Average earnings for men at $381/week are well below the peak of $402/week in 1979
□    Only women’s earnings are moving in the right direction, with 2016 at a new high of $312/week
□    But, of course, this highlights how women’s earnings still average only 82% of men’s earnings

It is no great surprise that US and global GDP continue to disappoint, given this evidence from the jobs market.  And nothing will change until policymakers accept that today’s ageing populations require completely new policies.

 

PREVIOUS POST

UK consumers face difficult times as Brexit unwinds the housing bubble, and financial services de-cluster out of London

06/04/2017

US GDP growth is slowing, again, as the chart of the Atlanta Federal ReserveR...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Trump, Xi have 100 days to avert US-China trade war

12/04/2017

US GDP growth is slowing, again, as the chart of the Atlanta Federal ReserveR...

Learn more
More posts
The BoE’s pre-emptive strike is not without risk
12/02/2019

The Financial Times has kindly printed my letter below, arguing that it seems the default answer to ...

Read
Flexible working is key to reversing today’s collapse in fertility rates
27/01/2019

Women in most parts of the world are not having enough children to replace our population. This is o...

Read
No Deal Brexit remains UK law unless MPs reverse their previous votes
20/01/2019

“That couldn’t happen” are probably the 3 most dangerous words in the English lang...

Read
CEOs need new business models amid downturn
14/01/2019

Many indicators are now pointing towards a global downturn in the economy, along with paradigm shif...

Read
Chart of the Year – China’s shadow banking collapse means deflation may be round the corner
16/12/2018

Last year it was Bitcoin, in 2016 it was the near-doubling in US 10-year interest rates, and in 2015...

Read
BASF’s second profit warning highlights scale of the downturn now underway
09/12/2018

The chemical industry is easily the best leading indicator for the global economy.  And thanks to K...

Read
Chemistry & the Economy: 2019 Outlook
04/12/2018

There will be no shortage of important topics to discuss on Thursday, at my regular Chemistry and th...

Read
Brexit moves from ‘Snakes and Ladders’ to cricket
02/12/2018

The Brexit debate had appeared to be a simple game of Snakes & Ladders till now.  The Leave cam...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more