Home Blogs Chemicals and the Economy FAANG stock prices start to tumble as the tech bubble begins to burst

FAANG stock prices start to tumble as the tech bubble begins to burst

Financial Events
By Paul Hodges on 30-Oct-2022

A year ago, investors couldn’t stop buying the FAANG tech stocks – Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix and Google, plus Microsoft and Tesla. Urged on by the media, they decided prices could never fall. But since then, the bubble has begun to burst quite spectacularly. And as I have suggested since January, more declines seem inevitable as valuations begin to return to more realistic levels:

  • Over the past year, Facebook/Meta is down 70%, Netflix is down 57%
  • Tesla is down 44%, Amazon is down 39%, Google/Alphabet is down 34%
  • Even Microsoft is down 29%, whilst Apple is the only one still positive, up 5%

The problem is that investors have forgotten how to actually value a company’s earnings. Instead, they have been trading on ‘the bigger fool theory’ based on momentum. Essentially their “analysis” was very simple:

“As long as I can find another idiot to buy from me at a higher price, I’m going to be okay.”

And, of course, they were encouraged by the mainstream media. It has mostly seen its role as being a cheerleader for the rally, as the Barron’s cover from August last year confirms.

But as I warned:

“Unsurprisingly, stocks have begun to sell off as traders realise they can no longer rely on the central banks to support the market. By the end of last year, it was really just 7 NASDAQ stocks keeping the bubble aloft:

  • Using Ben Graham’s long-time valuation formula, Tesla was the most over-valued by 3419%
  • Amazon was next at 760%, Netflix at 580%, Microsoft at 419%
  • Then there was Apple at 368%, Google (Alphabet) 320%, and Facebook at 280%

“These were clearly bubble valuations, and already they are starting to reduce.”

Unfortunately, as the chart shows using current prices, values still have much further to fall based on historical performance:

  • Tesla’s price at $226 is 659% higher than its Graham value of $34; Amazon is 1224% higher at $102
  • Netflix is 1331% higher; Microsoft is 293% higher; Apple is 290% higher
  • Google/Alphabet is 229% higher, and Facebook/Meta is 146% higher

Ben Graham invented stock market analysis and the concept of the Price/Earnings ratio after the disaster of the 1929 Crash. He believed investors needed some realistic valuation principles to guide their decisions.

But, of course, each generation has to relearn, painfully, what their parents learnt the hard way. This time around, politicians and central banks have combined to push valuations to absurd levels with their stimulus programmes.

One key mechanism was to make credit cheap and abundant, to encourage people to speculate with borrowed money. As the chart, based on FINRA data confirms, investors have been in the grip of a speculative mania:

  • Debt had hit a then-record high of $519bn ($2022) in February 2000 as the dotcom bubble burst and NASDAQ peaked at 5049
  • NASDAQ finally bottomed more than 2 years later in October 2002, by when it was down 78% from its peak
  • But in the 2010s a new generation of investors arrived, who knew nothing of the dotcom crash
  • And so history repeated itself as margin debt soared to $1tn, and NASDAQ raced to a new peak of 15,894 last December

Since then, investors have begun to realise that stocks don’t always go up. And that the FAANG stocks were just as over-valued in December as during the dotcom bubble.  Of course, hope springs eternal, as we have seen in recent weeks, when some investors thought they could “buy on the dip”. History suggests we will see several of these ‘false dawns’ before the market finally bottoms.