China full-year lending decline confirms that Fed pause is a sideshow

Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Environment, Europe, European economy, India, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea, Sustainability, Thailand, US

By John Richardson

CHINA’S full-year 2018 lending figures are out and they underline what I’d be warning throughout last year – the withdrawal of stimulus back to the levels of the pre-2009 period.

Shadow bank lending, which has led to extraordinary growth in demand for chemicals and polymers, and all the things made from chemicals and polymers, including autos, was down by no less than $684bn, as the above chart illustrates. Monthly lending via the shadow system averaged $20bn – the pre-2009 level.

2009 was crucial as it marked the beginning of the post-Global Financial Crisis surge in Chinese stimulus, the biggest the world has ever seen, which rescued the global economy from what would otherwise have been a much longer and deeper recession.

The global role that China played in stimulus is illustrated by the chart below, an updated version of the chart from fellow blogger Paul Hodges that I’ve been running for several years. It shows that up until China stimulus has dwarfed the stimulus by the Fed, the European Central Bank and the Bank of England combined.

This tells us that despite the recent rally in US equity markets because of signs that the Fed might be pausing on interest rate rises, there is little that the Fed or any other Western central bank can do replace the lost China stimulus.

The global implications of slower Chinese lending include the fall in German growth in 2018 to its lowest level since 2013. Germany is, of course, Europe’s biggest export powerhouse and is heavily dependent on exports to China.

What’s going to happen next

China will continue to put its foot down hard on the stimulus-acceleration pedal this year, but the law of diminishing returns will make the positive impact on its economy less than in 2009-2017. High levels of debt mean that the boost to GDP of each dollar of new lending will be less than during those nine years of extraordinary stimulus.

The easy path to a quick economic turnaround of building lots more factories can also no longer be followed.During 2009-2017, manufacturing plants were built for the economic multiplier sake of building the plants, almost regardless of supply and demand analysis. This led to oversupply in some chemicals and polymers an across many other manufacturing sectors. China cannot afford to add to oversupply.

The other problem is that building lots more factories would worsen China’s air, water and soil pollution crisis, which already represents an existential threat to society and the economy. Adding to pollution would undermine the commitment China’s leaders have made to deal with the crisis.

The slowdown in the Chinese economy is mainly to do with this withdrawal stimulus, which has taken the form of the sharp cut in the availability of credit.

But of course the trade war is also an important given that some 180m jobs in China are dependent on exports. The trade war was one of the reasons why China’s exports fell by 4.4% in December.

Some kind of trade deal between the US and China is a result increasingly likely, even though I believe that the underlying trade war/Cold War disagreements between the US and China will not be resolved. President Trump’s unpredictable behaviour is also a major threat. When it becomes apparent the trade deal lacks substance, he could pull the deal apart

BUT in the meantime the deal will give President Xi some breathing space and allow him to continue you with his economic reforms. So expect the credit squeeze to continue once a trade deal is done.

PREVIOUS POST

Oil prices to be buoyed by new shipping fuel rules, despite economic slowdown

13/01/2019

Guest blogger today is Ajay Parmar. He is a chemical engineering professional wi...

Learn more
NEXT POST

India's pollution crisis threatens chemicals industry approach to growth

18/01/2019

By John Richardson THE ten most polluted cities in the world are all in Northern...

Learn more
More posts
President Trump’s “better off without China” tweet not supported by the data
24/08/2019

The opinions in this blog post are, as always, my own and do not reflect the views of ICIS   By...

Read
How sustainability will upend the petrochemicals cost curve, creating new winners and losers
23/08/2019

By John Richardson THE FUTURE I described on Wednesday, of declining petrochemicals and polymers dem...

Read
How the Millennials and “less is more” are destroying petrochemicals demand
20/08/2019

By John Richardson WE HAVE gone beyond the point of no return because of a major societal shift. Mil...

Read
How we could all end up as losers from President Trump’s trade policies
16/08/2019

The views below are my own, and, as always, do not express the opinion of ICIS By John Richardson RE...

Read
President Trump’s tariff concession adds to uncertainties as we drift towards a bipolar world
14/08/2019

The following opinions are my personal views, and, as always, do not express the views of ICIS By Jo...

Read
China PE overstocking at above a million tonnes as Beijing struggles to boost economy
12/08/2019

By John Richardson EVEN IF our base case growth rate* for PE in China in 2019 proves to be correct t...

Read
China trade war duties on US LDPE “very likely” as global recession concerns grow
09/08/2019

By John Richardson IT IS very likely that China will impose 25% additional imports duties on LDPE in...

Read
US declaring China currency manipulator risks 10.8m tonnes of global petrochemicals demand
06/08/2019

  By John Richardson BY PLAYING with fire President Trump has very likely set the forest on fir...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more