China’s urban consumers depend on property ‘wealth effect’

Consumer demand

SHARE THIS STORY

China urban Feb14One of the great myths of modern times is that China is now full of middle class people with Western levels of consumption.  Nothing could be further from the truth.

Annual per capita incomes have certainly soared over the past two decades.  But the main impact has been to lift people out of absolute poverty, not to create a middle class on the Western scaleOfficial data shows

  • Average per capita urban incomes were Rmb 29547 ($4769) in 2013 versus $447 in 1993
  • Average per capita rural incomes were $1276 in 2013 compared to $160 in 1993
  • Equally important is that around half of the population now live in cities compared to only a quarter in 1993

But clearly, even average urban incomes are nowhere near Western definitions of middle class.

So why has there been so much confusion over this issue?

Shanghai prop Feb14The answer lies in the ‘wealth effect’ that has taken place as a result of the credit bubble.  This has inflated property values to an extraordinary extent, as shown by the Shanghai house price index chart from 2003:

  • Home prices have risen exponentially over the period
  • They continued to rise after the financial Crisis of 2008
  • This highlights how the government used easy credit to maintain economic growth.

The problem, however, is that wealth effects are essentially Ponzi schemes.  Those who join early get paid out with cash from those who join the party at a later stage.  But eventually economic reality breaks through, as there is nobody left to join.

This seems to be the case in China today:

  • City centre apartments in Shanghai are now selling for Rmb 47k/sq m ($7750/sq m; $720/sq ft)
  • Even apartments outside the centre sell for half this amount
  • Average prices are 29 times average earnings – several times the US subprime peak

Clearly these prices are unaffordable on normal calculations of prices versus earnings.  They only work when governments are prepared to supply low-cost credit with few questions asked about repayment, as in the US subprime era.   In China, this ‘wealth effect’ based on a property bubble has meant that millions of urban residents have appeared to become middle-class.

But in a Ponzi scheme, there had to be a new buyer able to afford to buy the property, each time the existing owner wants to cash out.  This becomes impossible once the tap supplying new credit is turned off:

  • Property transactions, always a leading indicator for prices, fell 31% in Shanghai in January versus 2013
  • Inventories of completed but unsold apartments in urban areas were 42% of annual completions in December

Another concern about the housing market is that ownership is very concentrated, as China Spectator has noted:

“The richest 1% per cent of urban households is also estimated to own around 30% of all real estate assets in the country. Using 2010 values, the richest 1% of households (2.1 million out of about 530 million households) own 40-50% of the country’s $US10.5tn real estate and financial assets”.

This doesn’t sound like a story that will end well, if the new government continues to cutback on the credit bubble.

Instead, consumer demand will be based on the chart above.  This shows government figures for per capita urban consumer expenditure in 2012:

  • Average spend was $2641:  food spend was $957 (blue), housing was $412 (red), transport $389 (green), clothing $289 (yellow), education $251 (light blue)
  • The poorest 5% spent $1157: food was $472, housing $173, clothing $93,  education $79 and transport $78
  • Even those in the top 10% spent only $5966: food was $1635, transport $1263, housing $939, education $672, clothing $622

Companies may prefer to believe that the government will ‘blink’ and do another stimulus package soon to maintain the wealth effect.  But it would seem prudent to also develop a Plan B, on the basis that the new leadership will carry through on its policies.

Failing to prepare for this possibility could result in a nasty shock.  China’s economy will be quite different when, not if, urban spending becomes based on income again, and loses the benefit of the wealth effect.

PREVIOUS POST

BBC reports 'How China Fooled the World'

19/02/2014

One of the great myths of modern times is that China is now full of middle class...

Learn more
NEXT POST

China's rural areas need basic goods, environmental clean-up

21/02/2014

One of the great myths of modern times is that China is now full of middle class...

Learn more
More posts
Smartphone market decline begins to impact global stock markets
19/05/2019

The bad news continues for the world’s smartphone manufacturers and their suppliers.  And Pre...

Read
There’s a great future for the European plastics industry in recycled plastic
05/05/2019

Europe’s plastics industry is under major threat from the growing legislative and consumer bac...

Read
$60bn opportunity opens up for plastics industry as need to eliminate single-use packaging grows
17/03/2019

150 businesses representing over 20% of the global plastic packaging market have now agreed to start...

Read
IKEA heads into the circular world with furniture subscription trial
10/02/2019

“Once upon a time, Granny and Grandad used to go to a large shop on the motorway to buy their ...

Read
Fed’s magic money tree hopes to overcome smartphone sales downturn and global recession risk
03/02/2019

Last November, I wrote one of my “most-read posts”, titled Global smartphone recession ...

Read
Global smartphone recession confirms consumer downturn
11/11/2018

Q3 smartphone sales data show the global market in recession, as Strategy Analytics confirmed: “Th...

Read
Trump’s auto trade war adds to US demographic and debt headwinds
06/08/2018

President Trump’s auto trade tariffs are bad news for the US and global auto industry, as the ...

Read
Plastics recycling paradigm shift will create Winners and Losers
17/06/2018

My new analysis for iCIS Chemical Business highlights the paradigm shift now underway in the plasti...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more