China petrochemical inventories build on what could be false hopes of a V-shaped rebound

Aromatics, Australia, Business, China, Company Strategy, Economics, Naphtha & other feedstocks, Oil & Gas, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea, Styrenics, Thailand, US

By John Richardson

AS PETROCHEMICALS storage space in China fills up on the hope that the country can lead the world in economic recovery, here are some important statistics for you to consider: 91% of the more than 500 Chinese companies surveyed by the China Beige Book had reopened by late April, but only 42% were able to operate at more than half capacity.

What if the recovery in China is not all that has been made out to be by the official statistics? There is every chance, in my view, that the official numbers are portraying an overly optimistic picture of the strength of the local economy.

I therefore maintain that there is a significant risk of a destocking process in petrochemicals and polymers in China later in Q2, especially given that I also remain unconvinced about the sustainability of the rebound in oil prices.

The rebound in crude is based on a questionable narrative of a V-shaped recovery in China, along with a smooth emergence from lockdowns in other countries. We all hope that the emergence from lockdowns will be smooth, but, sad,y. I am struggling to see how this will happen.

You have always had to take about 10% off the official economic data to get a more realistic assessment of Chinese growth. But up until this year the direction was always upwards and so the only question was the extent to which China was growing. Now, as the statistics from the China Beige Book illustrate, it is not clear whether China will grow in 2020. Its economy might very easily contract.

Another equally important number from the China Beige Book, a bottom-up data analytics firm, is the 69% of Chinese executives who said in another survey that April maybe “as good as it gets” over the next six months.

Please note, however, that petrochemicals market sentiment could be temporarily buoyed by an announcement of major government infrastructure spending during this year’s delayed National People’s Congress, which starts on 22 May.

But I do not believe that any amount of spending can be enough to guarantee the kind of V-shaped recovery in China that some people are predicting, as the economic damage from the coronavirus pandemic is too great.

Here in detail is why the 69% of executives surveyed by the China Beige Book could be right when they say that April was the best month for the next six more months:

  • The 6.8% official decline of Q1 GDP growth, which could be an underestimate, had left China with an enormous hole to climb out of during the rest of the year, even without a collapse in its export trade.
  • Exports of China’s manufactured goods to the rest of the world have collapsed due to the lockdowns. Even if emergence from lockdowns goes entirely smoothly, and that is a big IF, large volumes of unsold goods in storage and the loss of wealth make any recovery in export sales very unlikely during the rest of this year.

Offloading unwanted benzene

Net imports for some petrochemicals were down in Q1 this year versus Q1 2019 because of the fall in local demand in February-March and increased domestic production.

Benzene is the most prominent example where Q1 net imports were down 61% to 363,979 tonnes as local production climbed by 4% to 2.6m tonnes. This works out at a 14% decline in apparent demand growth versus our forecast that China’s 2020 full-year real demand will slip by just 1% compared with 2019 (real consumption is apparent demand adjusted for inventory distortions).

There however seems to have been a surge in benzene imports during April (the April import data will not be available until next week at the earliest) because arbitrage to the US is closed, demand in  other markets is weak – and, of course, because oil prices have gone up.

It seems likely that benzene producers and traders have also heavily targeted China in April to take advantage of the idea of a V-shaped local recovery. Buyers could have snapped up cargoes because the April macro-economic data was better than in March (the April data was expected to be better than March given that  China’s economy was largely shut down for the first two weeks in March).

Offloading unwanted benzene in China might have helped overseas steam cracker-based producers who are struggling to balance production. While ethylene and propylene demand has held up quite well because of demand for food packaging and other daily essentials, benzene demand has been significantly hit by the global collapse in consumption of durable goods. More than 50% of global benzene consumption is into durable end-use products such as high-impact polystyrene and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, I have been told.

An indication that benzene imports are out-of-sync with actual demand was the 207,700 tonnes of inventories in shore tanks along the east coast of China during the week ending 15 May. This was the highest level since the week ending 6 June 2019.

Ethylene glycols another example 

China’s mono, tri and d-ethylene glycol (EG) imports rose by 7% in Q1 this year over the same period in 2019 to 2.8m tonnes. As we do not track local monthly production, the increase could have been the result of a fall in local output, along with cargoes booked before the full extent of the coronavirus crisis became clear.

As local production is forecast to rise by 9% this year with demand down by 2%, it looks as if the Q1 shipments were excessive. This appears to be confirmed by our assessment of China’s main port mono-ethylene glycol inventories. As of the week ending 15 May, stocks were at more than 1.2m tonnes which was again the highest level since the week ending 6 June 2019.

Imports of paraxylene (PX), another polyester-fibre intermediate, fell by 11% during Q1 to 3.8m tonnes. This is hardly surprising given that domestic production is set to rise by 14% this year following an increase of no less than 34% in 2019.

But Q1 PX imports may still have been excessive if local purified terephthalic acid (PTA) markets are anything to go by. Last week, PTA Inventories were estimated to be at slightly above 4m tonnes, more than monthly demand. PTA futures warehouse receipts had been rising as more cargoes were placed into futures warehouses because of a lack of firm demand in the physical market.

The weakness in China’s EG and PX is the result of the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on demand for clothing.

China will account for a staggering 87% of total global EG net imports in 2020 among the countries and regions in the world in net import positions, according to the ICIS Supply & Demand Database. In PX, it is estimated that China will attract 93% of total global net imports.

China accounts for some one-third of total global net exports of clothing, according to the World Trade Organisation. It also dominates exports of polyester fibres and fabrics, made from its imports of EG and PX, to clothing factories in countries such as Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and India. The factories then export clothing mainly to the West.

Global EG and PX producers face some very difficult operating-rate decisions as, even assuming a smooth emergence from lockdowns, Western clothing retailers have large stocks on hand, especially in the fast-fashion sector. Clothing factories in the developing world are also going out of business because of cancellation of orders from the retailers, which is causing further supply-chain disruptions.

In conclusion, China has every chance of enjoying a strong recovery in 2021. But until then it is essential to be realistic about the pace of China’s recovery during the rest of this year. Do not be misled by the official data, be sceptical, and accept that China will not be able to easily absorb your surplus production.

And be cautious about the pace of recoveries in every other country and region over the next 12-18 months. Remember that cash is king and so to preserve cash, minimise your risks of overproduction.

PREVIOUS POST

Further polyethylene rate cuts seem inevitable with no certainty on who will blink first

18/05/2020

By John Richardson IT IS NOT just a razor-like focus on petrochemicals demand th...

Learn more
NEXT POST

Beware of the fragile nature of the oil and petrochemical price recovery

22/05/2020

By John Richardson RECENT rises in oil and petrochemicals prices should not in m...

Learn more
More posts
China bans on single-use plastics move forward with major recycling investments likely
22/09/2020

By John Richardson THIS EVENT slipped under most people’s radar in the midst of the pandemic crisi...

Read
Developing world polymers demand unlikely to see quick rebound
20/09/2020

By John Richardson THIS IS a tragedy in the genuine sense of the word, not just in the so-often misu...

Read
China’s policy dilemma: raising local demand while protecting exports
13/09/2020

  By John Richardson IN THIS Western-centric world, a huge amount of ink is split over the cons...

Read
China’s polyethylene demand good so far in 2020 but beware of risks ahead
10/09/2020

Note that all the comparisons in this post are on a year-on-year basis unless otherwise stated By Jo...

Read
Ah, I see: China’s booming demand mystery a little closer to being solved
08/09/2020

  Note that all the data comparisons below are on a year-on-year basis By John Richardson THE P...

Read
The China polyester mystery continues in a world turned upside down
07/09/2020

By John Richardson SOMETHING very strange is happening in China’s polyester industry which has eno...

Read
China will struggle to boost local retail sales during rest of 2020 with export outlook uncertain
04/09/2020

By John Richardson IF IT were easy, then there would be an oversupply of owners of large yachts in M...

Read
Pandemic and the developing world: No quick and easy solutions
01/09/2020

By John Richardson POVERTY alleviation in low-income developing countries could be set back a decade...

Read

Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more

Analytics

Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more