A little bit of China stimulus goes a long way in housing

Economic growth


China housing Oct13It was only a “mini-stimulus” that was delivered by China’s new leaders in July.  Well, thank goodness it wasn’t more, to judge by the above chart from Albert Edwards at SocGen.  It shows how house price inflation has jumped in 69 of China’s 70 main cities between March and September:

  • In March (orange column) inflation was averaging between 2% – 4% versus March 2012
  • By September (red) it was averaging between 6% – 9% versus September 2012
  • Prices in hot spots such as Beijing and Shanghai were up 20%
  • Only Wenzhou saw falling prices, now down for 23 months as its private sector slows

The problem is a mix of naiveté, greed, and the lack of a comprehensive state-run social security system.

The naiveté comes from the fact that China only began to develop a private housing market in 1998.  Until then, all urban housing was built and allocated by the state.  There was no word in Chinese for ‘mortgage’.  In rural areas, peasants built homes on land allocated by the state.  So people have no history to guide them.

The greed comes from the fact that house prices have never fallen in the past 15 years.  There have been a couple of brief slowdowns in 2008 and 2012, but the government quickly responded with measures to support the market.  So most people now assume prices will continue to double every two to three years.

The lack of basic social security, coupled with the ‘one child policy’ means young men wanting to marry are expected to own a home.  “Housing, a stable income and some savings” are ‘must haves’ when meeting the prospective father-in-law.  With only 100 women for every 117 men, he can insist that the groom is able to support his daughter.

Thus the supposed ‘mini-stimulus’ has caused prices to race ahead again.  Everyone believes that the government would never let prices fall.  The only problem is that those of us living outside China know this is wishful thinking.  Either the government will finally take firm measures to crash the market, fearing major financial instability and social unrest.  Or the bubble will pop of its own accord.

Meanwhile, for the moment, the situation remains out of control, as the Financial Times noted last week:

“Property prices have almost quintupled in leading Chinese cities over the past  decade and they are perhaps the biggest single threat to the country’s economic and social stability. For the economy, the fear is that China is in the middle  of a property bubble that will eventually burst and trigger a financial crisis.  For society, frustration about housing prices is widespread and their continued rise only fuels more discontent.”


Lessons from Grangemouth - how Europe can revive its industrial base


Sometimes a crisis can concentrate minds on one key issue.  This was certainly ...

Learn more

US becomes 'The Snail Economy' as its population ages


There comes a moment in a debate when the argument is clearly won, and discussio...

Learn more
More posts
No Deal Brexit still a likely option if opposition parties fail to support a new referendum

Canada’s normally pro-UK ‘Globe and Mail’ summed up the prevailing external view of Brexit las...

UK, EU27 and EEA businesses need to start planning for a No Deal Brexit on 31 October

New UK premier, Boris Johnson, said last week that the UK must leave the EU by 31 October, “do or ...

London house prices edge closer to a tumble

After the excitement of Wimbledon tennis and a cricket World Cup final, Londoners were back to their...

G7 births hit new record low, below Depression level in 1933

If a country doesn’t have any babies, then in time it won’t have an economy. But that...

From subprime to stimulus…and now social division

The blog has now been running for 12 years since the first post was written from Thailand at the end...

Resilience amidst headwinds is key for H2

Resilience is set to become the key issue as we look forward to H2, as I note in a new analysis for ...

Perennials set to defeat Fed’s attempt to maintain the stock market rally as deflation looms

Never let reality get in the way of a good theory. That’s been the policy of western central b...

Europe’s auto sector suffers as Dieselgate and China’s downturn hit sales

Trade wars, Dieselgate and recession risk are having a major impact on the European auto industry, a...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more