Policymakers’ faith in US Confidence Index badly misplaced

Economic growth


Consumer conf Nov13There was an interesting discussion at our annual conference last week about the relevance of correlation statistics.  The general view was that anything less than 90% wasn’t really worth bothering about, as the number of errors would be too great.

Thus the blog was very amused to see Neil Irwin in the Washington Post writing about the major US confidence indicator (hat-tip FT Alphaville).  He has checked back to see the correlation between the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment indicator and actual consumer spending.

This is an indicator that has been produced since 1978.  And it is routinely used by US government and Federal Reserve officials to forecast consumer spending, as well as being cited each month in most mainstream media.  Consumer spending is, after all, the most critical economic variable as it is 71% of the US economy.

There is just one problem, as Irwin notes in discussing the chart above:

“The two have only a 4.5% correlation from 1978 through the present, meaning that knowing what happened to one tells you pretty much nothing about what happened to the other”.

So there we have it.  Policymakers happily spend their time studying the Confidence Indicator, and using it to draw conclusions about the outlook for the economy.  They have never thought to test its predictive power.  Yet they choose to ignore demographics, which has to be the key driver of demand.



EU, US caustic soda output slows as China's exports rise


Chlorine and caustic soda are some of the most widely used chemicals.  Thus th...

Learn more

US polyethylene and PVC exporters focus on margin, not volume


2013 has seen 3 types of markets develop for the blog’s IeC Downturn Moni...

Learn more
More posts
The world has wasted 3 months – there is little time now left to avoid a Covid-19 catastrophe

It is now 3 months since China’s state television broadcast the first news of the Wuhan virus,...

A new recession era to emerge

Contingency planning has become mission-critical. The longer the coronavirus pandemic continues, the...

Chain’s smartphone and auto sales tumble as coronavirus hits demand

China is the world’s largest market for smartphones and autos – responsible for c30% of ...

China’s lockdown makes global debt crisis now almost certain

Beijing has a population of 21.5 million, but you wouldn’t know it from this BBC video from la...

Financial markets head for (another) train crash as coronavirus starts to impact

China’s industrial heartland of Hubei (pop 59m) and its capital Wuhan (pop 11m) have now been ...

Coronavirus disruptions make global recession almost certain

Last month, our Hong Kong-based pH Report colleague, Daniël de Blocq van Scheltinga, warned of the ...

Your A to Z Guide to the Brexit trade negotiations

A. Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty set out the rules for leaving the European Union. As with most ne...

Contingency planning is essential in 2020 as “synchronised slowdown” continues

The IMF has now confirmed that the world economy has moved into the synchronised slowdown that I for...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more