5 years of stimulus have only delayed move to the New Normal

Consumer demand, Financial Events

Stocks Mar14Coincidentally the blog began its 6-monthly review of global financial market performance on 7 March 2009, as the US market hit its post-Crisis bottom.  At this point, it was possible to hope that central banks would allow markets to resolve the issues that they themselves had created.

After all, there would have been no subprime crash if the US Federal Reserve and other central banks had not kept interest rates low from 2003 onwards, in order to create a property ‘wealth effect’ and boost consumer spending.

Unfortunately, central banks refused to accept the lesson they should have learnt, having seen financial markets crash.  Instead, they decided to double up on their failed policies and operate on a ‘shock and awe’ basis, as Fed Governor Charles Plosser confirmed last week.

The chart therefore compares developments in the major markets since 6 March 2009, in relation to each market’s pre-Crisis high, to see how successful they have been:

  • Bond markets were the early winners: the US 30-year bond rose 41% by its September 2012 peak (purple)
  • The US S&P 500 (green) and Germany’s DAX (orange) are also above their previous peaks, up 20% and 16%
  • India’s Sensex pre-election rally (black) has taken it back to parity: the UK FTSE (pink) has followed the US
  • Japan’s Nikkei (light blue) has jumped since H2 2012’s stimulus began, but is still down 16%
  • Brazil’s Bovespa index (brown) did well initially, but is now down 37%
  • Russia’s RTS (red) is now down 53%, whilst China’s Shanghai index (blue) is down 66%

This is not a great result, given the $33tn of stimulus that has been spent since 2009.

Of course, US stock market investors have done well, as have bond investors till recently.  But most of the US population own very few shares.  As the US Senate Finance Committee has reported:

Most Americans have saved only a fraction of what they need for retirement. Workers approaching retirement age have an average retirement savings of less than $27k.  One third of Americans aged 45 – 64 have nothing saved for retirement at all.

“The numbers are no better for workers with a retirement plan. In 2010, 75% of Americans nearing retirement age had less than $30k in their retirement accounts.  For minority workers the situation is dire, with a median retirement account balance of $30k.  80% of Latino households age 25 – 64 have less than $10k in retirement savings.”

Equally worrying is that a major cause of the US markets rise has been record borrowing by investors.  Margin debt on the New York Stock Exchange has risen 160% over the past 5 years to an all-time record of $451bn – even higher that 2007’s peak of $381bn.

It would have been better by far if central banks had learnt their lesson from the financial market collapse of Q4 2008.  It was clearly essential that they acted as a ‘lender of last resort’ after having caused most of the financial system to freeze following their foolhardy decision to allow Lehman to go bankrupt.

Had they allowed markets to fulfil their role, policymakers would have been forced to confront the key issue, that ageing populations can never have the same growth rates as when they were younger.  Consumer sending is, after all, between 60% – 70% of GDP in Western countries.  And those aged 55+ already own most of what they need, and their incomes decline as they enter retirement.

But we don’t have that choice today.  Instead, we have lived in a dream world for the past 5 years.  Central banks pretended that demographics have nothing to do with demand.   And they argued that increasing asset prices would somehow power a recovery in consumer spending.

Picking up the pieces from this mistake will not be an easy task over the next 5 years.  Bond prices have recently weakened, as investors start to realise that it will be impossible to repay the debt that has been built up.  And the downturn in 3 of the 4 BRIC markets (Brazil, Russia, India, China), suggests that investors have begun to realise it is wishful thinking to hope these could somehow replace lost Western growth.

As we set out in ‘Boom, Gloom and the New Normal’, demographics drive demand.  Not even central banks can turn 55-year olds back into 25-year olds


China focuses on domestic PE production, ME/SEA imports


China’s growth has been the main support for the global economy since the ...

Learn more

India's car buyers remain cautious despite pre-election tax cut


Its pre-election time in India, as the world’s largest democracy prepares ...

Learn more
More posts
The Top 5 pandemic paradigm shifts

The Covid-19 pandemic has accelerated the fundamental changes which were already underway in global ...

Economic risks rise as the lockdowns end

It is now 13 years since I wrote the first post here, in June 2007. A lot has happened since then: ...

Hertz goes bankrupt as non-essential consumer demand disappears

The US Federal Reserve has now spent $7tn bailing out Wall Street. But it couldn’t save the 10...

Smartphone sales head into decline as affordability becomes key

The smartphone sales decline accelerated in Q1, as Strategy Analytics report: “Global smartpho...

China’s property sector is at the epicentre of the crisis

A branch of Centaline Property Agency in Hong Kong © Bloomberg Indebted Chinese property developers...

“They may ring their bells now, before long they will be wringing their hands”

The wisdom of Sir Robert Walpole, the UK’s first premier, seems the only possible response to ...

China’s plastic ban and recycling launch marks end of ‘business as usual’ for plastics industry

Paradigm shifts start slowly at first, and it is easy to miss them. But then one day, they suddenly ...

Automakers face stiff headwinds in big emerging markets

Brazil, Russia, India and China disappoint as manufacturers face investment demands of EVs © Bloomb...


Market Intelligence

ICIS provides market intelligence that help businesses in the energy, petrochemical and fertilizer industries.

Learn more


Across the globe, ICIS consultants provide detailed analysis and forecasting for the petrochemical, energy and fertilizer markets.

Learn more

Specialist Services

Find out more about how our specialist consulting services, events, conferences and training courses can help your teams.

Learn more

ICIS Insight

From our news service to our thought-leadership content, ICIS experts bring you the latest news and insight, when you need it.

Learn more